In my OP I asked the person how they figured we were talking about a bill of attainder. I got back an incorrectly reasoned response. I looked at the majority of responses and figured it was going to take more than I was willing to expend.
I just put it in with the misunderstood free speech issue and let it roll.
>> I got back an incorrectly reasoned response <<
Not the least bit unusual around here these days.
So I simply lean back and enjoy the passing parade.