Posted on 08/17/2017 6:35:26 AM PDT by Red Badger
Updated 17 Aug 2017 at 6:20 AM
In the aftermath of violence at a white nationalist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, progressive activists nationwide have demanded, and in some cases illegally carried out, the tearing down and removal of statues and monuments to Confederate leaders and soldiers on public space. Now Black Lives Matter activists have gone even further going so far as to call for a ban on all Confederate imagery even in private possession.
Inspired by Germanys post-war laws banning any and all Nazi imagery, Black Lives Matter activists on Twitter called for a similar ban on Confederate imagery or memorabilia.
After WWII, Germany outlawed the Nazis, their symbols, salutes & their flags. All confederate flags & statue, & groups should be illegal, tweeted the Black Lives Matter Chicago Twitter account, @BLMChi.
"The fact that the Confederate flag & statues permeate the south is evidence that white supremacy was never overthrown in the United States," the @BLMChi account tweeted three minutes later.
Outlawing all Confederate flags, symbols, statues, and groups would not only be indescribably impractical taking into account the existence of battlefield monuments, graves, Civil War re-enactors, every single souvenir shop within a 10-mile radius of Gettysburg, historical computer games, and Lynyrd Skynyrd albums it would also be illegal.
Article continues below
"Even the most liberal Supreme Court justice knows that the remedy to hateful or offensive speech is opposing speech," Eddie Zipperer, an assistant professor of political science at Georgia Military College, told LifeZette. "This would be a blatant violation of the First Amendment."
"Leftists always haul out the argument that you can't yell 'fire' in a crowded theater, so free speech has limits," he said. "But that argument is nonsensical. Historically, the Supreme Court goes to any length to protect political speech even wildly unpopular speech."
Zipperer provided as an example the decision in the 2011 case Snyder v. Phelps, in which the court ruled 8-1 to "protect the absolutely horrible, hateful speech of the Westboro Baptist Church during a protest of a dead soldier's funeral."
"That case was decided by all the same justices we have now, except Scalia was on the court instead of Gorsuch," he noted. "The Supreme Court has allowed almost no limitation on political speech, and there's no reason to think that will change."
Similar rhetoric pointing a finger of wrong at any and all Confederate memorabilia came from at least one lawmaker.
"Confederate memorabilia have no place in this country and especially not in the United States Capitol," said Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.) in a statement to The Hill.
The entire Congressional Black Caucus called on Wednesday for the removal of all Confederate-related statues in the nation's Capitol.
"The Congressional Black Caucus and the Black Lives Matter movement ignore the reality that the central figures in Confederacy, from Robert E. Lee to Jefferson Davis, were also central figures in American political life," said Dr. Lee Cheek, a professor of political science and history and Dean of the School of Social Sciences at East Georgia State College.
"Most of the more important figures were the children of heroes or veterans of the American Revolution," Cheek continued. "For example, CSA Brig. Gen. and Secretary of War George W. Randolph was the grandson of Thomas Jefferson. Lt. Gen. Richard Taylor, CSA, was the son of General and President Zachary Taylor and the grandson of a Revolutionary War officer."
"As the great American historian Dr. Clyde Wilson has noted, there are hundreds and hundreds of these historical connections; in other words, this is an American story as well as a Civil War story that should be shared with the rising generation in its fullness," he said.
"The greatest threat to Congressional Black Caucus' new 'cultural revolution,' inspired by an illiberal and anti-democratic worldview, is an environment in which free and uninhibited discussion and disagreement can take place," Cheek continued.
"In fact, diversity of thought is the opposite of their desires, but is at the heart of a free society. The proponents of historical cleansing are on the ascendency, and the authentic study of the American South is the victim," he said.
The particular assault on statues of Gen. Robert E. Lee showcases the degree to which emotion has overridden important historical context.
Robert E. Lee, that alleged symbol of white supremacy and racism, not only personally opposed overt displays of Confederate symbolism after the war but also believed that the entire war the Confederate defeat and the personal loss of his Arlington property and fortune was worth it to see slavery ended.
"I am rejoiced that slavery is abolished," said Lee in 1870. "I believe it will be greatly for the interests of the South. So fully am I satisfied of this, as regards Virginia especially, that I would cheerfully have lost all I have lost by the war, and have suffered all I have suffered, to have this object attained."
A very small step, now, to criminalization of everything they do not like.
Very dangerous and treacherous ground they are treading on. It takes only a very small shift of opinion within the mob for things that are now acceptable to be denounced tomorrow, and a whole new class of criminals is instantly defined.
And so many of them would be otherwise victimless crimes.
George Orwell would be humbled, to see that so many of the projections he saw in both “Animal Farm” and “1984” are now the new reality. Command and control has never been a very good thing for humanity, but it is apparently the default position for mobs.
For the same reason they don’t know anything. They are low IQ morons. They don’t even know how to manufacture basic rifle ammunition.
I suspect the Republicans will have a surge of support in the South.
Stepin Fetchit?...............
Black race-bigots have declared war on everybody else. We are ALL at war, whether we realize it or not.
By the way, that thing in post #24 has a cross necklace on.
Mao’s cultural revolution has come to the USA
And here we thought obama’s Mao WH Christmas tree ornaments were just a lil joke on us
So my biographies about Confederates would be outlawed? Good luck with that.
I would settle for just being prosecuted.
OF course white people could stop this but they won’t so this nation will devolve to the point of eradicating anything in the least bit associated with slavery or ‘racism’.
‘White Privilege’ indeed.
As long as folks are going to ignore the Constitution...
* Ban all communist imagery (flags, che images, etc) since communism was the greatest crime against humanity the world has ever known
* Ban all “pan-african’ or kwanzaa imagery as it’s all just code for ‘Kill whitey’
* Ban all ‘feminist’ imagery and symbols since Dworkinistas want to kill all the males
... etc ...
The left should not be the only ones who play the morality card. Infanticide is at least as disgusting as racism. So let’s defund professors, such as Peter Singer, who, right now, advocate infanticide, if we are going to destroy monuments to racism from long ago.
And in the midwest.
A BIG FU TO BLM AND THE BLACK CAUSUS
It’s like watching a train go off the rails. Honestly what exactly are they thinking as a political party endorsing and supporting this kind of group?
Everyone should display a lawn jockey if this becomes law
Obama’s press secretary had Communist propaganda posters framed on the walls of his home.
“Im already afraid to wear my Lynyrd Skynyrd tee shirts in public.............”
As long as it covers your holster...what’s the problem?
Is a brilliant BLM person like this one behind it?
good Lord...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.