Pudgy...? To a nineteen year old nothing is “pudgy”
Especially in Alabama. LOL
Certainly not to the point of inducing "trauma".
Dunno about you, but when I (and my friends) were 19....
If the girl was still breathing, had bathed in the past year, and didn't have a beard like a Confederate General .... we were good. That's a pretty low standard, right there, and for some, the "bathing" part might have been negotiable.