You make up meaningless fantasy worlds that don’t exist and want a discussion based upon them.
I live and work in the real world. I’m not a fantasy writer. Pretending the world doesn’t exist doesn’t have any meaning in the real world.
Making markets smaller never end up in lower prices. You really should take a couple economic classes.
People of high intellect always construct scenarios that point out the edges of theory to better understand the workings and understand flaws. Some people are up to the challenge some aren't and as trained engineer I do this all the time. Test the limits and boundary conditions, go to edge that is where the real learning comes from . You seem incapable of that. Frankly you are either a coward or stupid in this particular case.