Posted on 04/20/2015 4:11:08 AM PDT by Homer_J_Simpson
I refuse to take part in any illegal activity....
The leftist revisionist historians want to re-write history regarding dropping the bombs, claiming we really used them because:
1) We were racists
2) Japan was ready to surrender
3) We wanted to intimidate the USSR
Reading Homer’s daily posts from the Times shows how ridiculous those arguments were. And as bad as the bombs were, I shudder when I think of the alternatives of NOT using them, or of the Japanese not surrendering after we did. Those terrible bombs SAVED LIVES; American, Asian, and yes, Japanese. Lots of Japanese.
That’s why, of all the possible “what if?” scenarios about World War II, I won’t engage in any about the end of the war against Japan. I don’t like to consider the alternatives.
The logjam could only be broken by the Emperor throwing his support to the one condition plan. Fortunately, the U.S. accepted it.
So much for the revisionists who claim Japan would have surrendered anyway. Even after two atomic bombs dropped the Cabinet was still unable to vote on a clean surrender.
At the time, about 40% of Japan's larger cities were destroyed. The atomic bombs saved lives just from the perspective of avoiding further conventional bombing. Throw in the horrific military and civilian casualties a conventional invasion would have created and the decision was clear. The revisionists, like most liberals, have to rewrite history and invent facts for their position to make any sense.
Ditto. My dad had just returned from combat in Europe and in August was at home on a thirty-day furlough before shipping out. His division (20th Armored) was scheduled to be in the first wave to hit Tokyo Bay in March '46, and they expected 100% casualties.
I’ve been saying that for decades.
The Chinese Nationalists only look like good guys when compared to the ChiComs.
And the Finns had to make the best of a couple of really bad options.
One other thing dropping the bombs did, it most likely saved Japan from being divided like Germany and Korea, into Soviet and Wester Allied zones, and with it, most likely a Civil War.
Heaven help us if Tojo followed through on his plan to kill the Emperor.
True about the Finns. Although they did a fairly good job holding out against the Soviet for being a small nation, the Soviets did pound them to bits. Germany reached out a hand to help them. I cannot blame the Finns one bit because of their situation. At least the Finns put in conditions where their Jews and other minorities were not to be harmed so ironically, you had Jewish soldiers fighting alongside the Germans.
Yeah, I wonder how long we would have to fight Japan had we had to take her without the A-Bombs. It could have gone on to 1948, maybe 1950. The other thing could have happened is a Soviet North Japan and a free South Japan and instead of the Korean War, we could have had the Japanese War. Japan is basically a nation on mountainous rocks, there would have been plenty of hiding places for their Army and resistance to hide as well as squirrel away what weapons they had left.
It would have handed China and all of Korea to the USSR no later then 1947, maybe as early as late 1946. The Russians might have passed on Japan in exchange for all of mainland Asia right away. The Soviets would have a free hand in Asia as long as we were embroiled in Japan.
I really don’t like to think about how the world would have turned out if Japan didn’t surrender in August 1945.
Can’t say I blame you.
They buried Ernie Pyle today. So close to the end. BTT
That only came after Barbarossa. During the Winter War, the Italians tried to send them planes,and the Germans embargoed the shipment.
A lot of us would never have been born.
Not quite - the Soviets did grab a chunk of northern Japan - one reason there still isn't a peace treaty. The Reds grabbed the southern part of Sakhalin Island and the Kurils. Some of the land grab was conceded by Japan, but some of it is still disputed.
Yeah, but that was small potatoes compared to what would have been. Soviets probably would have gotten all of Hokkaido and probably half of Honshu, with perhaps even Tokyo itself divided, like Berlin.
Buchenwald, was not a “Death Camp” per se, it had many non-Jewish prisoners.
That would have been nice.
Hitler VS. Stalin, the original Alien VS. Predator.
Nice comparison!!!
National Socialist versus International Socialist...
Family Feud.
But... the REAL difference is... Better boots.
Germans had better boots. Looks better - stylish, even - when it’s on yer neck.
It’s a fashion thing. One must have a sense of style, after all...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.