[Salvavida]

You are on to something. What if FR commissioned the crafting of an appropriate medal, and the process of nominating and adjudicating candidates of Counter Jihadist Heroes?

[naturalman1975]

That's a different thing - and we do have private decorations here as well, from a couple of sources.

I'm not sure what America should do - Australia's honours system evolved out of the fact we are a Monarchy, and for us, it's appropriate. A Republic might make different decisions for perfectly valid reasons. But I do note that you do have some elements of a civil honors system already - the Presidential Medal of Freedom and the Presidential Citizens Medal.

I think our system is appropriate because it provides very clear, very real formal recognition of both heroism and other forms of service by civilians. I think America could probably find such a tradition worth having.