Agreed however the judge ordered the DOJ to complete the index AND to specify how the application of executive privilege applied to each document.
DOJ failed to do that and just made a blanket assertion to cover all the documents. The judge seems rather fed up with DOJ's continued disrespect for the court and stone walling and this could really piss him off.
This is just one judge. Obama will ask for a stay and then appeal to the Obama judges on the DC federal court. Guess what they will do?