I am an avid reader. I prefer science fiction and thriller genres. I read for escape and as a process. I also have a couple of unfinished novels on my computer. Various reasons, mostly plot-related or I get too busy IRL.
However, I am reading a LOT of indie authors recently. I read quickly, so I run out of material if I wait for the *pros*. The indies vary in quality, and yes, many need an editor, not just for grammar, syntax and spelling, but because they often include pages of eye-numbing detail that should be back story and revealed incrementally through action or dialogue. For some reason, retired military logistics officers often try writing as a retirement career and they are THE worst at this sort of listing. It must be because they compiled so many lists in their former jobs.
I think going indie is a viable route. If the novel is truly bad, it simply won’t sell much due to word of mouth reviews. And if it is good, it will rocket to the top via the same.
Indie writers are no different from professional crafters. They create a product and then have to market it. Marketing is more difficult than creating. But the creator will work harder than any publisher and often this makes the difference in success.
Exactly what value to their employers are the professional gatekeepers providing?
Would the industry be better if there was a volunteer submissions that people could submit to and people would read the material and the ratings and reviews would signify something that had potential?
If Joe Blow across the street can dig up talent as well or better than me - then I ought to be fired.