[highball]

Would you remain a member of a "gay church" because you and a small group of opposing parishioners thought you could somehow redeem it?

The Catholic Church now admits it has a "gay lobby" trying to influence policy; should Catholics cut and run when that lobby eventually wins its first battle, or stick it out to fight the war?

[steve86]

The Catholic Church now admits it has a "gay lobby" trying to influence policy; should Catholics cut and run when that lobby eventually wins its first battle, or stick it out to fight the war?

The reason your analogy fails (although clever to posit it) is that the "gay lobby" in the Vatican is in direct opposition to the (unchanging) teachings of the Church (and the pope). In contrast, in the case of the scouts, the leadership is pushing the homo agenda. Couldn't be more different.