It sounds fake because, how do you find three people stupid enough to feel SO threatened by a woman’s homosexuality that they get together to commit felonies upon her and for what end result?
I suppose it could happen and it may be that it did. I’m just explaining why it doesn’t pass the smell test.
You nailed it: It doesn’t pass the smell test. The cops must be on to it , as all say, just biding their time until she “cracks”. If this is true, I’ll be shocked.
The only circumstance where I could see three straights beating up a gay, would be if the gay person had molested one of their kids. They wouldn't carve anything on her, though -- that particular act sounds like something a woman would do to another woman.
BINGO! That plus the fact that she somehow freed herself from the ropes PLUS the incredibly precise lettering the perps supposedly wrote on the wall.