[cripplecreek]

Seems to me that he wants to create an unconstitutional citizen/non citizen hybrid that the supreme court would legalize to citizenship inside of 18 months.

[Jagdgewehr]

Bingo

[rintense]

That’s basically what’s happening in Texas with in-state tuition for illegals. They get tuition breaks (including state aid) under the premise they have applied for citizenship. You therefore have a group of people in citizenship purgatory. It’s is exactly as you say it is... a citizen hybrid. Wait until Newt and others say they should be given the same rights as true US citizens. It’s coming, folks.

[TomGuy]

Seems to me that he wants to create an unconstitutional citizen/non citizen hybrid that the supreme court would legalize to citizenship inside of 18 months.

Gingrich proposes a path to non-deportation.

Gingrich is actually trying to create another class of residents.

We have citizens. We have legal aliens. We have illegal aliens.

Gingrich wants to create legal non-citizen illegal residents.

We already have too much confusion in this country regarding illegals. We don't need legal non-citizen illegal residents to complicate the issue even further.

Red Card? Typical political canard that is just more Washington non-solution BS to make a problem appear to be resolved, while creating a potentially worse future problem -- and bigger bureaucracy to handle Red Card issues.

[magna carta]

Cripplecreek...you nailed it.