There might be another problem here... Is the guy in Vermont, Arizona, or Alaska who is from Illinois not allowed to carry by this travesty?
No, reciprocity is an “affirmative agreement”, which means that citizens can enjoy the greater benefit between states, not restrictions.
This was recently at issue in Arizona, as no permit of any kind was required, but the state needed to provide a permit to anyone who wanted one to prove in another state with a reciprocity agreement with Arizona that they didn’t need a permit, even if in that state they needed a permit.