First the stimulus, now the hangover

Last week's dismal jobs figures tell us exactly what the President Obama's stimulus did: It temporarily saved jobs in state and local government -- thereby slowing our recovery.

Friday's job scorecard for September -- the last before Election Day -- didn't carry even a hint of an imminent boom. Unemployment stayed at 9.6 percent, with private companies adding 64,000 jobs.

And 64,000 jobs is nothing. The economy must create nearly five times that to keep up with population growth and replace 7.6 million jobs lost since 2007.

Worse, the new hires were down a third from August -- and the positions were low-paying, in bars, restaurants and retail.

The report also told us that people who have jobs aren't working much overtime. That means companies aren't overwhelmed by unexpected business -- and won't need to do a lot of extra hiring for the holidays.

The big headlines went to the drop in government jobs. Local and state government lost 83,000 jobs -- the biggest hit in modern history. Teachers lost the most, with school districts cutting nearly 58,000 after summer break.

Government > Agency Listing (State Agencies) Related FAQs Agency Listing (State Agencies)

Adirondack Park Agency Aging, Office for Agriculture and Markets, Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, Division of (State Liquor Authority) Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Services, Office of Arts, Council on Assembly, New York State Attorney General, Office of Authority Budget Office Banking Department Battery Park City Authority Bridge Authority, New York State Budget, Division of Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning and Policy Commission, The Chief Information Officer, Office of New York State Children and Families, Council on Children and Family Services, Office of City University of New York Civil Service, Department of Community Renewal, Ofice of Consumer Protection Board (En Español) Corcraft Products (Dept. of Correctional Services, Division of Industries) Correction, Commission of Correctional Services, Department of Correctional Services, Division of Industries (Corcraft), Department of Court Administration, Office of Criminal Justice Services, Division of Cyber Security and Critical Infrastructure Coordination, Office of Developmental Disabilities Planning Council Dormitory Authority Education, Department of Elections, Board of Emergency Management Office, State (SEMO) Empire State Development Employee Assistance Program, NYS Employee Relations, Governor's Office of Employment Relations Board, NYS Energy Research and Development Authority Environmental Conservation, Department of Environmental Facilities Corporation Erie County Fiscal Stability Authority Family Assistance, Department of Financial Control Board, New York State General Services, Office of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) Clearinghouse Governor's Office Governor's Traffic Safety Committee Health, Department of Higher Education Services Corporation Homeland Security, Office of Housing and Community Renewal, Division of Housing Finance Agency/State of NY Mortgage Agency (SONYMA) Hudson River Park Trust Hudson River Valley Greenway Hudson-Fulton-Champlain Quadricentennial Commission Human Rights, Division of Inspector General, Office of the Insurance Department Insurance Fund, State Judicial Conduct, Commission on Labor, Department of Local Government Efficiency & Competitiveness, Commission on Lottery, Division of Medicaid Inspector General, Office of Mental Health, Office of (En Español) Metropolitan Transportation Authority Military and Naval Affairs, Division of Motor Vehicles, Department of Nassau County Interim Finance Authority New York State Commission on Higher Education New York State Law Revision Commission NYS Canal Corporation Office of Victim Services (En Español) Olympic Regional Development Authority Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, Office of Parole, Division of People With Developmental Disabilities, Office for Port Authority of New York and New Jersey Power Authority Prevention of Domestic Violence, Office for the Probation and Correctional Alternatives, Division of Public Employment Relations Board Public Integrity, Commission on Public Service, Department of Quality of Care and Advocacy for Persons with Disabilities, Commission on Racing and Wagering Board Real Property Tax Services, Office of Regulatory Reform, Governor's Office of Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation of the State of New York Science, Technology and Innovation, NYS Foundation for Senate, New York State South Shore Estuary Council State Comptroller, Office of State Employees Federated Appeal (SEFA) State Police, Division of State University Construction Fund State University of New York (SUNY) State, Department of Tax Appeals and Tax Appeals Tribunal, Division of Taxation and Finance, Department of Teachers' Retirement System Technology, Office for Temporary and Disability Assistance, Office of Thruway Authority Transportation Federation, The New York State Transportation, Department of Veterans' Affairs, Division of Welfare Inspector General, Office of the Workers Compensation Board Contact Information for State Agencies Contracting with New York State Federal Government Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) Funding Programs Grants Information for Government Entities Lobbying Local Government Information Military Open Meeting Webcasts State Government Veterans Voting / Elections

RE :”And private companies created few new jobs after 2000 — and then managed to lose them all, and more: Private job growth is minus 2 percent over the last decade — there's 2.2 million fewer private workers to pay for those 1.6 million new public-sector workers. In short, when it comes to private job growth, the last decade has been a lost decade. A big part of the reason: State and local governments never got around to adjusting to the last recession. After the tech bubble burst, the private sector shed 3.5 percent of its jobs over two years, or nearly 3 million. But the public sector kept on hiring through the early-2000s slump. Politicians added 5 percent (647,000 people) to local payrolls and 3 percent (167,000 people) to state ones. Most of these new workers — nearly half a million — were, yes, teachers and education administrators. Back then, because local and state pols chose to spare their workforces the pain, they had to inflict it somewhere else. So states like New York and California spent the early 2000s raising taxes, slashing infrastructure investments and taking on debt.
That should have left them with no choice but to start firing public workers two years ago, when the bottom fell out of their tax revenues. (After all, the construction industry depends on the same source of revenue — property values — as do local governments, and residential-construction jobs are down 31 percent since 2000.)
Instead, the 2009 stimulus law sent more than $220 billion to state and local governments — without asking them to pare their workforces or workers’ benefits. But now the stimulus cash is running out. So the state and local government jobs that it “saved” are starting to disappear, as governments around the nation do what their voters have been doing for three years now — cutting back. “

This busts the myth of the great job expansion the last 10 years.

The liberal Keynesian dogma doesn't allow for the above(cutting government) . It says when private sector hiring stops then government needs to hire more to pick up the slack in demand(Chris Matthews calls it the “...best economic minds following the best thinking ...”.) Alternatively when the economy recovers we must grow government even more because we are a ‘rich nation that can afford it’, they call it 'economic justice'.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.