Dersh may be a lefty on most things, but on Israel he’s right on!............
No, both he and Gould are wrong. And, not just simply the wrong of flawed analysis, but the tragic wrong of blind, slavish devotion to their own ideology while failing to grasp that of the enemies of Israel who are absolutely committed to the destruction of Israel, and who openly state in their own "internal dialogue" that any and all agreements with Israel are merely tactical "hudna" and "taqiyyah" to buy time until their own version of a final solution can be achieved.
Melanie Phillips is the one who's dead-on correct on this issue. It is truly discouraging to see the number of Freepers who, for whatever reasons, can't seem to wrap their minds around the reality of these issues.