[domenad]

While this gentleman had a reasoned and law-supported viewpoint, I don't believe he's taking into account the fact that Gates was following the officer, who had left the house because he could not communicate effectively with his dispatch. Following, shouting, and screaming at an officer who is actively trying to put some space between you, all the while interfering with his communication, is more patently disorderly conduct. If Gates had just stood in his house and harrangued away, I would say that's free speech.

[marktwain]

I have read at least one report that stated that the officer asked Professor Gates to step outside of the house, and that it was stated in the police report that this was due to “poor acoustics” in the kitchen. If true, it puts a completely different spin on the issue.