Posted on 05/29/2009 5:50:10 AM PDT by sukhoi-30mki
Fed up of delays, India shops for non-Russian platforms
Express news service Posted online: Friday , May 29, 2009 at 0115 hrs
New Delhi : In an articulation of India’s annoyance over nagging delays in several key defence acquisitions, New Delhi finally seems to have decided to reduce its dependence on Russia for military hardware. Two key upcoming acquisitions that Moscow would have liked to believe it had in the bag — the next batch of three aircraft for additional Airborne Early Warning and Control Systems (AWACS) and six refueling aircraft for the Air Force — are all set to be given to non Russian companies. The signal was clear on Thursday morning at the induction ceremony of India’s first AWACS when an unusually vocal A K Antony publicly asked the Russian ambassador to ensure that defence equipment is delivered in time.
He also took on the Israeli ambassador for delays in the Phalcon AWACS that were delivered a year-and-a-half behind schedule. Russia, followed by Israel is one of the two biggest suppliers of military equipment to India.
Antony’s outburst against delays by Russia has been preceded by action from the Indian Air Force. A top official confirmed that in the follow on order for three additional AWACS, that is likely to be placed by 2012, the Russian IL 76 aircraft will be replaced by a different plane.
While the first three Israeli AWACS to be delivered by next year will be mounted on the Russian IL 76 aircraft, when the next order is placed, the aircraft used will either be the American Gulfstream or Brazilian Embraer jets.
“We will replace the IL 76 by a modern aircraft like the Gulfstream or Embraer. Both have an endurance of nine hours that is close to what the Russian aircraft has,” an official said.
While the ageing IL 76 is one concern, the real trouble for Russia seems to be its inability to deliver the aircraft on time for the AWACS deal that was signed in 2004. Sources said that Russia overshot its schedule for modernisation of the IL 76 aircraft with new engines and avionics, leading to the programme going back by a year-and-a-half.
Another deal that Moscow would have thought it had secured — additional refueling aircraft for the IAF — is also set to go the European Airbus 330 MRTT. This comes as a surprise as India’s current fleet of air-to-air refuelers are Russian IL 78 aircraft. It would have been easier to place a follow on order for the Russian tankers and would have been far easier to operate them as maintenance facilities already exist in the country.
However, while the Russian aircraft was also considered for the contract, the IAF has placed it below the Airbus in the crucial flight evaluations that decide the procurement. IAF says that the Airbus scored way above the Russian aircraft and has given it as its preference for the contract.
India’s reluctance to order additional Russian platforms comes from several delayed deals that have been impeding defence modernisation. While in the past, smaller delays were ignored, the experience with the Gorshkov aircraft carrier was the final coffin in the nail.
Besides delaying the delivery of the carrier by over four years — it was supposed to be inducted by 2008 — Russia surprised India by asking almost twice the agreed amount for refurbishing the warship.
India could always go for the Boeing 737 based Wedgetail that is being built for Australia, but it is over 3 years behind schedule...
Or the 767 based platform used by Japan.
India has very smart engineers and access to resources...they should be building their own military stuff which I’d bet would be quite innovative if they gave them’selves a chance.
Go India!
Buy your stuff from (in this order of preference):
1. USA
2. UK
3. Israel
4. France/Germany
99999. Russia
Go USA!!
Go Texas!
India please buy some JSF made by Lockheed right here in DFW.
God Bless!
Yes, India measures up to any country when it comes to intellectual abilities.
Since emotional tones don’t come out well in written responses were you agreeing with me or being sarcastic?
I wouldn’t be mad either way...just couldn’t tell for sure. I mean Americans make jokes about Indian telemarketers and that sort of thing, but I really think they have the potential of becoming a great technological super power...greater than China. The Chinese imitate, but the Indians I believe, when freed from ancient cultural biases could grow to be a great innovative nation!
1. China
2. USA
3. India
I was in complete agreement :-)
The fear in India is that the US Congress often tends to stick a spoke in the wheel when they feel like it, for whatever reasons.
Like in 1999, during the Kargil War, India had to turn to SouthAfrica and Israel for ordnance because the West put a kibosh on supplies.
The ordnance expended was far beyond what India had anticipated in such a short period of time. Abysmal planning perhaps, but when crunch time came, they got squat apart from the aformentioned countries.
I do know that the Dallas area is often used by Bollywood production teams when they want to have a hassle free location in the USA.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.