Posted on 09/23/2008 8:09:41 AM PDT by sukhoi-30mki
That junk is pretty much the only thing on the market for the Indian navy. The F-16 is not carrier capable, the Super Hornet is too heavy and the Rafale is too expensive. Moreover, the Russians would have jacked up the price of the carrier, if not cancelled the deal altogether if the IN didn’t buy Russian jets.
Buying the Gripen would mean the end of the LCA programme. For all its delays, I don’t see any Indian government pulling the plug on the LCA. OTOH, the Super Hornet and Eurofighter have an advantage in the competition in that their engines are being considered for an upgraded LCA , which would not only ease the logistics situation for a bloated airforce, but also bring LCA close to the Gripen in capability.
The Gripen also has considerable foreign content- a radar developed with French help and an American engine. Those governments can deny export licenses during critical negotiations. Countries have done that before.
That would leave only the French and the Russians, because the french would not impose sanctions, just jack up the price. For the stated aim of replacing the Mig 21, its great, but as you say, other considerations would put it at the bottom of the heap, along with the F-18.
How do the costs compare, the Gripen v/s the Eurofighter and the Russians?
The Gripen has a great advantage on initial and life-cycle costs. The Eurofighter is probably the most expensive jet in the competition and the fact that it’s producers will most probably cut orders is not going to help it. The Mig looks like a no-show given the current chill in Indo-US ties as well as the unpalatable scenario of having three Russian systems (SU-30/fifth-gen. fighter and Mig-35) at the same time.
My own preference would have been the Gripen, but I assume that the Super-Hornet is a front runner for political and commercial reasons.Can’t rule out the Rafale too.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.