Posted on 03/24/2008 3:34:30 PM PDT by blam
Perhaps you should ping Jim Robinson and have him rename the site “Free Agora”. (-:
The 'School of Athens' fresco by Raphael, housed in the Vatican, is meant to represent the Greek agora and all the great minds that passed through it. Credit: Heather Whipps
The Athens Agora. The temple to the right is the Hephaisteon which for many years was an Orthodox Christian Church. Arguably, it is the best preserved temple in Greece. The other contender is the Temple of Apollo at Bassae.
It all started long before the Greek agora. Even backward African tribes had their open area with the huts around it for that socialization, long before the Greeks were civilized.
So agoraphobia is...?
it is actually more sophisticated a concept and exchange of ideas than just an open area around huts.
I have seen many of the ancient locals and their agoras. I have even seen their weekly “agora” where farmers bring their wares.
It is just as much a polical as commercial discourse.
You don’t think the African natives used to gather in the central area and discuss the climate and other political issues?
|
|||
Gods |
Thanks Blam. |
||
· Mirabilis · Texas AM Anthropology News · Yahoo Anthro & Archaeo · · History or Science & Nature Podcasts · Excerpt, or Link only? · cgk's list of ping lists · |
Civilization btt.
That’s what they did indeed. But it didn’t lead anywhere. That’s the difference.
Ooh! Desktop background booty!
never said they would not.
However I think the Hellenic model is a bit differnt in that it was not “just a spot” but an actual archetected location with that intention from the start.
For example to the right of the picture above near the plaka is a water clock mechanism (I have actually been there and there is an excellent History Channel documentary covering it) which told time for the whole area.
It was more than just a “village” level of transactions and discourse, it was a commercial draw for surrounding villages. Its creation is akin to our modern day creation of supermalls with clubs and theaters.
either way its is all good.
Later, of course, but the agora began as a place for the surrounding farmers to sell their food to the town-dwellers. The same set-up has been used all over the world, for many centuries. I will grant you that the Greeks made good use of it for politics, but I'm sure other cultures had the same thing. The Romans copied the Forum from the Greek agora, but the Greeks probably copied it from somebody else.
on that you could argue the central location in a cave by the cave dwellers was an “agora”.
but as the article indicates and more than a few papers on the subject, the exchange of ideas is the major inovation. It was not just a place to dump out your veggies and sell them and discuss “ows da weather” in polite conversation.
It was the functional equivalent of their FreeRepublic with a store feature.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.