True, those who are in the military against their will don't make good soldiers, I witnessed that first hand.
I had this same discussion with a group of dems last week. They wanted the draft because, and I use their own words, “It would weaken the military so much that Bush would have to stop his insane war.” I responded with a question, “So you support weakening our military in the time of war?” I never got another response from any of the 4 dems in the email discussion. They quickly changed the subject.