Reporter Angita Sangita
Posted on 07/28/2007 9:45:41 PM PDT by Stoat
Reporter Angita Sangita
The BBC was dragged into a fresh row over standards after police claimed it broadcast a misleading investigation into child-trafficking.
The report, which led BBC1's Ten O'Clock News on Thursday, purported to expose Bulgarian criminals offering toddlers for sale to British couples for £40,000 each.
But Commissioner Veselin Petrov, head of police in the Bulgarian city where the undercover report was filmed, has insisted that there is no evidence of organised criminals selling children.
Petrov accused the BBC of entrapping 'Harry', the alleged trafficker, by offering him money, and threatened to charge the reporters with incitement, an offence that carries a prison sentence of up to a year. The BBC adamantly deny that they offered any money.
The row comes just a week after a number of senior BBC staff were suspended in the wake of revelations about faked phone-in competitions.
The trafficking report, which was presented by Sangita Myska and took a three-strong team a month to film, was produced in an unusual drama-documentary-style format.
'Harry', whose identity was revealed as 39-year-old Hasan Ahmed Hasan when he was arrested two hours after the coverage aired, was filmed being asked to provide a baby for a British businessman.
Scroll down for more...
'Harry': Offering to smuggle children to Britain via France and Ireland
He was secretly recorded boasting that he had previously smuggled children across Europe and demanding €50,000 to €60,000 (£33,600 to £40,200) to move a child out of Bulgaria with false adoption papers and into the UK via France and Ireland.
Later, toddlers were brought to a cafe by their families and shown to the BBC team, although none changed hands.
The film did not conceal the identities of the children, who were aged about two, although the pictures on the BBC's website were pixellated to disguise their faces.
Mr Hasan, whose Bulgarian wife lives in Scotland, was identified as a member of a criminal trafficking gang, but Commissioner Petrov, head of police in the resort of Varna, said there was no evidence this was true.
Scroll down for more
Bulgarian mother shows off her toddler during the BBC investigation
"According to our information, the BBC's investigation was flawed," he said. "We have found nothing to back up claims of an organised group selling children for €60,000."
Neighbours who know Hasan added that they would not be surprised if he had taken money from the BBC's journalists to fabricate the story, but doubted he was involved in baby-trafficking.
Commissioner Petrov said it was a "sad day" when an institution such as the BBC should "fall so low".
"The BBC led this man on with the promise of vast riches," he said. "He was provoked to give the journalists what they wanted.
"If they had not presented the problem in a way that one of them had been childless for ten years and was desperate for a child, then Hasan would not have agreed to help.
"The journalist . . . promised he was ready to ensure a wonderful life for the child and his family. He suggested he was well intentioned and that everything would be legal.
"If the BBC had managed without lures and incentives to uncover a trade in babies, it would have been a brilliant story, worthy of the highest honour.
"But the reality is something quite different."
He also accused the BBC journalists of delaying the arrest of Hasan until the report was aired by giving his officers false information.
He added: "Although substantial sums of money were offered, none of the parents seems to have been persuaded to part with their children."
Bulgarian police released Hasan without charge and said that, if he is ever charged, it will not be over trafficking but in connection with the more minor offence of inciting a parent to put a child up for adoption.
Under Bulgarian law, the punishment for this is a £350 fine or up to a year's imprisonment.
Commissioner Petrov said Hasan had no criminal record in Bulgaria, Britain, or Ireland, where he lived for nine years.
But he added that he was once detained in Germany on suspicion of involvement in trafficking women for prostitution, but he did not know if that came to court.
BBC sources claim to have evidence that he has a conviction in Germany for trafficking.
The Mail on Sunday asked the BBC whether it had paid any money to Hasan and why it had not obscured the children's identities. It initially refused to answer, saying only that the investigation had followed its own editorial guidelines.
But after it saw our first edition, the Corporation said: "No money had been offered or changed hands at any time."
Ten O'Clock News editor Craig Oliver said: "The BBC fully stands by its report. It was clearly in the public interest and was carried out according to strict BBC guidelines.
"We informed the relevant Bulgarian authorities, including the National Police Service, and also provided them with material to help identify the subjects of our investigation well before our report went on air.
"I am disappointed that the head of Varna's police force has made these misleading remarks."
He added that Commissioner Petrov's allegations were "libellous".
A BBC source said the news team avoided approaching local police because of allegations of corruption.
BBC admits fake winners on charity appeals (staffers posed as winning callers on air)
BBC BOSS TAKES A BITE (Director General of the BBC bit colleague on the arm 17 years ago)
BBC in row over doctored TV footage with Gordon Brown (....made him look like a thug)
Craven at the BBC (Islam treated with fawning reverence, Christianity with near-disdain)
Swear box (BBC TV hits rock bottom with Jerry Springer The Opera - thousands of obscenities)
I’m not so sure what all the fuss is about....Dan Rather here in the USA would regard this as “a shining example of journalism at it’s best”
I know some immigrants (legal) from Russia, and they said kidnapping of Russian children and putting them up for adoption as orphans is quite a business. Kidnappers go after children with parents because they are well taken care of and healthy and don’t have adjustment issues that real orphans have. These kidnapped kids are much more adoptable. And, of course, they get them young enough so that they are cute as all get out....., and can’t speak yet, so they can’t tell anyone what is really going on.
My friends were terrified when they had to go to Moscow for any reason.
This doesn’t surprise me, and I do believe it.
The CNN of Britain.
Based on events in the last month...the Queen’s episode, the fake radio call-in winners, etc...the BBC is walking a very thin line. If this story goes through with proof showing they did offer money...the Chief of the BBC will have to resign, and probably the next two or three guys after him will have to go as well. The governor’s board that controls the situation...has little patience. Even the union within the BBC is shocked just sharp the board has become and they really don’t even care how the union reacts. If the Union wanted to go on strike...no one would care.
At the best, I’d say the present chief might slide out of this episode if firm proof can’t be shown...but he is simply waiting for the next episode. The public is fed up with the lack of confidence here.
I don't think that any thoughtful person can deny the existence of child smuggling....it's frequently in the news and is a recognized international problem affecting many countries.
That being said, it seems that in this specific instance there are serious irregularities in the journalistic integrity of the story. Just because child smuggling exists doesn't mean that all accounts of it are true, and the BBC has garnered a reputation for fabrication, particularly recently.
This is probably posted elsewhere on FR, but sound like that reporter missed:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/07/25/nbbc125.xml
It’s going to be hard for the BBC to ask for more TV licence money....:^)
IIRC, about $300 per household to just own a TV... sheesh!
Sounds like something that that scumbag NYC mayor would do, like he did with the straw purchases of guns.
Varna, Bulgaria is a tourist destination.
The police chief’s job in a tourist spot includes making the speech that its safe to come there.
This kind of reporting, which went out on the “BBC World” channel as well, tends to discourage tourism in his town.
Who wants to take their small children to a town where this kind of stuff is going on?
After the Madeline McCann kidnapping in Portugal, this issue is on the minds of people in the UK.
The BBC is the “Hate America Network” and slanted badly, but this story is probably more credible than some of the other crap they put on.
Isn’t it astonishing that they feel it’s completely reasonable to effectively ‘teach honesty’ to ostensibly adult professionals? An essential foundation of a person’s character which either is or is not formed in childhood is viewed as merely another plank in the all-encompassing Socialist model of Governmental bureaucracy and control.
And when people fail in such a basic part of life as honest behavior, it’s viewed not as a moral failure which deserves societal condemnation, scorn and the levying of significant penalties to the offenders but a deficiency in ‘education’, to be addressed by yet another layer of bureaucracy.
It’s yet another illustration of how Socialism destroys humanity by replacing it with bureacracy.
Thanks very much for posting your interesting and informative yet simultaneously depressing link.....it could serve as an example of what happens to a culture that succumbs to Socialism.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.