Posted on 05/31/2007 8:45:09 PM PDT by Omega Man II
McClatchy exclusive: Bush accuses conservative critics of fear-mongering on immigration
By Ron Hutcheson - McClatchy Newspapers
Firing back at conservative critics, President Bush defended his plan to overhaul immigration laws Tuesday and accused its opponents of "trying to rile up people’s emotions" with misinformation.
In an exclusive interview with McClatchy Newspapers, Bush expressed his determination to fight for changes that would let millions of illegal immigrants gain legal status. He cast the debate as a struggle over America’s soul and its reputation as a welcoming nation.
"I’m deeply concerned about America losing its soul. Immigration has been the lifeblood of a lot of our country’s history," the president said during an interview on Air Force One. "I am worried that a backlash to newcomers would cause our country to lose its great capacity to assimilate newcomers."
Bush underscored his commitment to the proposed overhaul — despite harsh criticism from some conservatives — as he traveled to Georgia for a speech that blasted the legislation’s critics.
"I’m sure you’ve heard some of the talk out there about people defining the bill. It’s clear they hadn’t read the bill. They’re speculating about what the bill says, and they’re trying to rile up people’s emotions," he told an audience at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center in Glynco, near Brunswick. "If you want to kill the bill, if you don’t want to do what’s right for America, you can pick one little aspect out of it, you can use it to frighten people. Or you can show leadership and solve this problem once and for all."
Bush acknowledged that the proposed overhaul faces a difficult time in Congress, where it’s under attack from both ends of the political spectrum.
Conservative critics contend that it amounts to an amnesty program because illegal immigrants would be allowed to stay in the country after paying $1,000 fines. Some liberals complain that plans for a new temporary worker program are overly restrictive and would create a permanent underclass of foreign workers.
Some of the most vociferous criticism has come from conservative talk-show hosts who usually back the president. Commentator Rush Limbaugh has told his listeners that the legislation would doom the Republican Party and the nation.
The bill seeks to strike a balance between tougher border enforcement and a more welcoming policy toward the estimated 12 million immigrants who already are in the country illegally.
Bush hopes to push it through Congress with help from a bipartisan group of lawmakers that includes Sen. Edward Kennedy, D-Mass., a liberal stalwart, and Sen. Jon Kyl, R-Ariz., a staunch conservative. The president said he had no hesitations about working with Kennedy despite their sharp differences over Iraq and other issues.
"The reason why is, he can get the job done," Bush said aboard Air Force One.
Sitting in his spacious office on the presidential aircraft, Bush traced his commitment to immigration to his time in Texas.
"When you grow up in Texas like I did, you recognize the decency and humanity of Hispanics. And the truth of the matter is, a lot of this immigration debate is driven as a result of Latinos being in our country," he said. "I have seen firsthand the beautiful stories of people being able to take advantage of opportunity and make solid contributions to our society."
He said Americans had nothing to fear from large-scale immigration from Latin America.
"There is an element of our society that is worried about two Americas," he said. "Our ability to welcome newcomers and the system’s capacity to assimilate them has been one of the great powerful traditions of America. It works, and it will work this time. People shouldn’t fear our capacity to uphold our motto: E Pluribus Unum."
The Latin phrase means "Out of many, one."
Addressing one of the most sensitive issues in the measure, Bush expressed hope that the changes would reduce the need for a fence along the border with Mexico.
The bill requires the completion of at least 370 miles of fencing, along with other security measures, before any temporary worker program can go into effect, but doesn’t specify how much of the border ultimately will be fenced. Congress approved legislation last year calling for 700 miles of fence.
The proposed fence has drawn protests in Texas, where officials fear it will hinder commerce and cause environmental problems.
"The fence sends a clear signal that we’re serious about enforcing the border," Bush said. "A lot of these ranchers down there are saying, `Wait a minute. Bad idea.’ I presume we’re not going to build a fence on places where people don’t want it."
“People shouldn’t fear our capacity to uphold our motto: E Pluribus Unum.”
That ain’t the phrase we are worried about nor arguing.
“Reconquista” is.
(I know there’s about 15,000 empty apartments in Camden,NJ, that ought to take care of a mil or so)
Amnesty isn’t just a path to citezenship. This plan will give instant amnesty to probably a lot more than 12 million. Maybe closer to 20 million. Once these people get instant amnesty, they can bring in their families from home. This may add another 20 million sooner rather than later.
This is too large a shock to our society. It is a slap in the face to be called a fear monger just because I don’t want this.
A week ago that figure was 5,000.00, but since it is really nothing, and the touch back is for two are three minutes, and both have hardship waivers, it is just BS for the dumb folks.
Dear President Bush-
For the most part we support you sir...but on illegal immigration, we respectfully disagree sir.
Sit down Bush...you’ve down enough harm.
So, in 2000, conservatives busted their asses to stop Gore from taking the Presidency away from Bush.
In 2003, we supported Bush against the anti-war "Bush lied" moonbats.
In 2004, we supported Bush when Dan Rather tried to smear Bush's honorable service in the TANG.
There were other times when we backed the President when he was under an unprecedented assault from liberal hate and the Democrats, his judicial picks, his SS reforms...
So how does Bush repay us.
Why, he repaid us by continuing to reach out to these same scumbags that want to display his head over the fireplace and bearskin rug.
Compassionate conservatism, New Tone, and all that jazz.
We overlooked his Medicare Part D boondoggle, his Harriet Meiers, his Dubai Ports dealing, his LBJ spending spree that makes Slick look fiscally conservative * cough 30 billion for AIDS in Africa cough *
But the line in the sand has been drawn. All Americans do not support the AMNESTY that the President is promoting, to please the WSJ and the US Chamber of Commerce, as well as corporate trans-nationals and big business.
I will not support any GOP ticket that includes Jeb Bush.
The only way this makes any sense is if the NATU stuff is true.
A country cannot be easily dissolved if it’s still populated by its citizens, but flood it with foreigners who have no stake in or loyalty to the country and dissolution is made very easy.
This has to be stopped at this point.
These "newcomers" don't want to assimilate, and that's because they're well on their way to conquering the U.S. demographically.
“I’m deeply concerned about America losing its soul. Immigration has been the lifeblood of a lot of our country’s history,” the president said during an interview on Air Force One. “I am worried that a backlash to newcomers would cause our country to lose its great capacity to assimilate newcomers.”
President Bush, legal immigration is 100% totally acceptable to me and millions of other Americans. Illegal immigration is not. The hispanic community is, in far too many cases, not the least bit interested in assimilation. I fear that you are putting the immigration cart, before the border security horse.
I’m deeply concerned about America losing it’s LAW, LANGUAGE, and CULTURE.
Sounds like Georgie boy is more interested in changing us than protecting our heritage.
Does anyone else besides me think Bush is pushing greenhouse gas cutting and immigration “reform” because the dems backed off on Iraq????
I’m starting to think there was a back-room deal.
Teddy has indeed been "getting the job done" on the immigration issue for a long time now; unfortunately that "job" is to destroy the United States.
“”Does anyone else besides me think Bush is pushing greenhouse gas cutting and immigration “reform” because the dems backed off on Iraq????””
It’s a payoff to Tony Blair. It’s not the first time he’s done this for Blair.
At least he didn’t commit to carbon markets, so maybe his concession is clever.
What more will it take for Republicans in Congress to begin impeachment of this arrogant creep? Last week it was amnesty. Today he joined Al Gore’s crusade. How much more damage can our nation and our party endure from Bush? Impeach now!
Sit down Bush...you’ve down enough harm.
Imagine how many liberal concepts he could have pushed if the WOT had not came along.
I don’t think there was any back room deal...I think it is a little thing called “legacy”..... Pres. Bush has my vote of NO CONFIDENCE!!!!!!!
WRITE! WRITE! WRITE! WRITE! TILL YOU RUN OUT OF INK IN YOUR PEN!
Bombard the Democrats as well, especially the ones that ran on an anti illegal immigration plank and the ones in marginal districts who could be vulnerable. keep pounding on them. This is a bipartisan issue not a Conservative or Liberal issue BUT AN AMERICAN issue.
Sounds like he’s talking about the vast right wing conspiracy.
Why do I feel like I’m beating my head against the wall, while my fearless leader sits and parrots the same tired BS.
Sir, we don’t care if they’re from South of the Border, we care whether they are here legally. We care if they are criminals. We care if they are physically ill!!!
As our fearless leader sits in his spacious AF1 office, fingers in ears, singsonging “lalalalalala” :(
Prediction: President Bush is a pretty stubborn person. He won’t quit fighting for this no matter what.
We gotta kill it in the Senate, hopefully. If not there then in the House. IMHO, the “blue slip” has wings.
Bush has been unfairly attacked by the Democrats who don't really want to fight the terrorists, so I hesitate to criticize him. But Bush is wrong on immigration. He is just encouraging more illegal immigration.
Na, just helping stop another Miers decision.
Things that make you go “Hmmmmmm.....”
For the most part we don’t support you, a**hole Bush!!! This man is doing more damage to the conservative movement than any politician ever has. His stance on open borders is deplorable.
Fine heavily employers who hire illegal aliens on the first offense. Second offense is jail time. Cut all social services off for illegals. Anchor babies are no longer given citizenship. Employ these three tactics and the illegals will go home.
Until then vote THIRD PARTY!!!!!
That said, we do have to remove incentives for illegal immigration
“Why do I feel like I’m beating my head against the wall, while my fearless leader sits and parrots the same tired BS.”
You are! Vote THIRD PARTY.
“(I know there’s about 15,000 empty apartments in Camden,NJ, that ought to take care of a mil or so)”
ROTFLMAO!!
Maybe some know now but attack Bush to make the Bushbots hold on all the harder..
Pretty smart if so..
Amnesty has been a goal of his since 2004, at least.
I accuse Bush of betraying this nation’s sovereignty to Mexico.
Bush is obtuse......or just plain evil. I report, you decide : )
Just the 2nd time? He’s been betraying us openly since 2004, at least. Earlier, really. He wasn’t as blatant about it.
Vote THIRD PARTY
If you are beating your head against the wall now, vote third party; let the RATS get in and they will beat your head into the wall. (Dear Mr. President, Up Your Bucket Sir!)
That's a lie, right? My understanding is that immediately upon enactment of the bill, illegal aliens could apply for "Temporary Z Visas", and basically have the ability to renew them forever, (thus making the "triggers" part of the bill a complete hoax).
Additionally, these "Temporary Z Visas" would require a "background check" to be done within a 24 hour maximum time frame, but that's not logistically feasible, meaning virtually EVERY illegal alien would get one. Additionally, I believe these "Temporary Z Visas" do not require payment of any fine, do they?
Do I have all this right?
Bush and this author Ron Hutcheson are liars, right?
Bravo Omega well said!
You know, if this amnesty crap keeps up, the Republicans WILL be the "THIRD PARTY".
Good grief. That guy has been toast ever since he let a county probate judge stare him down. Weak.
Actual Bill
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c110:S.1348:
Some shortcummings:
http://www.jdhayworth.com/26reasons.html
I think know Bush’s thinking:
1. make money
2. easier transition of legals and illegals
3. no harassment the 14th amendment.
Walk on Water conservatives got the Rat congress they wanted and now they are being taught a lesson. Hopefully this bill fails like the last one and there will be NO immigration reform.
Pray for W and Our Troops
Damm, come to think of it........
You mean the Congress Bush wantd. The one he could “work with” was, I believe, the line?
That is such an ignorant statement. Any time you classify a whole ethnicity or culture of people is stereotyping, whether good or bad. As if all Hispanics are the same. What a joke.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.