Posted on 05/18/2007 10:44:13 PM PDT by MatthewTan
Breaking News: Iowa State Department Faculty Acknowledge ID Played Role in Gonzalez's Tenure Denial
According to a story to be published in the May 26 edition of World Magazine (already available online here), two faculty members of the department that denied tenure to Guillermo Gonzales at Iowa State University have admitted that his work on ID played a role in the denial. While Prof. Eli Rosenberg, Chair of the Department of Physics and Astronomy, insisted to the magazine that intelligent design "was not an overriding factor" (emphasis added), he then conceded according to the magazine that Gonzalez's pro-ID book The Privileged Planet "played into the decision-making process. He also explained that the reputation of a professor among others in his field is a significant factor." Of course, if "reputation" is used as a code word for whether one's views are popular among fellow scientists, then this is another way anti-ID bias entered into the decision.
But Rosenberg is not the only department member who admitted that intelligent design played a role in the tenure decision.
ISU astronomy professor Curtis Struck told World that he was not surprised at the denial of tenure to Gonzales because "[h]e includes some things in his astronomy resumé that other people regard as taking a coincidence too far." Struck was obviously referring to Gonzalez's arguments for intelligent design.
Struck's comments mean that at least three of the five tenured astronomers in Gonzalez's department have now been tied to anti-ID bias. As noted earlier this week, another tenured astronomer in the department signed a statement circulated by the National Center for Science Education denouncing intelligent design as "creationist pseudoscience," while the husband of a third astronomy professor signed the same statement.
Despite his own admission, Prof. Rosenberg tried to do damage control by claiming that there was something deficient about Dr. Gonzalez's sterling research record: "You take a look at somebody's research record over the six-year probationary period and you get a sense whether this is a strong case. Clearly, this was a case that looked like it might be in trouble." Really? Was Gonzalez somehow derelict in publishing 350% more peer-reviewed publications than his own department's stated standard for research excellence? Or in co-authoring a college astronomy textbook with Cambridge University Press? Or in having his research recognized in Science, Nature, Scientific American, and other top science publications?
It is worth pointing out that in early 2004 Gonzalez's department nominated him for an "Early Achievement in Research" award for an outstanding record in research. So what changed between 2004 and 2006 when Gonzalez submitted his tenure application? Well, 2004 was the year The Privileged Planet was published. Dr. Gonzalez continued to publish peer-reviewed journal articles, and even co-authored the Cambridge University Press textbook in 2006, but his department seems to have soured on him just as the controversy over intelligent design heated up on the ISU campus and around the nation. Coincidence... or design?
Isn't the answer obvious?
Intelligent Design asserts that the universe is more than matter and energy, that your intelligence is more than atoms and molecules and electrical waves.
Intelligent Design asserts that we are in the era of matter+energy+intelligence.
The distinguished French biologist Pierre Grasse says of DNA, "This intelligence is sine qua non of living things".
Paul Davies, “Our ability to understand and discern the universe is a fundamental part of what makes the universe tick, so that we are linked into it. This isn’t just an accident, to be a trivial little byproduct; it is linked to the great cosmic scheme of things. Now, I have no idea how that linkage works, why it’s there, or anything of that sort, but I am very, very struck by the fact that we can understand the universe in such exquisite detail at such a deep level.”
Logic and reason sustains the entire universe.
This is not about any religion. It is about rationality in the universe. The physics and mathematical equations tell us so.
ID is science just as materialism is science. If ID is not science, then materialism is not science and has to be banished from science classrooms. ID theorists have been discriminated and denied tenure.
Support Gonzalez. Support academic freedom. Let the science of ID challenge the science of materialism.
Hummm... newbie... doggedly, dogmatically, relentlessly posts about one topic and one topic only.
To comment, or not to comment, that is the question.
or was that zot?
Yeah, but it’s not about science. Try as you may, you cannot redefine science to suit your so-called rationale.
LOL
Gonzalez is going to be a very wealthy in the not too distant future.
I do not know of any.
And exactly how long do you have to be a member before intelligence is bestowed, I find your post highly insulting and irrelevant.
ID is not science. Science deals with the natural world.
ID looks at the natural world, finds something we can't currently explain and makes the great and illogical leap to the supernatural.
And you claim that ID is science?
Reminds me of Clarke's Third Law:
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
I don’t have a problem with ID as long as the Intelligence behind the design is specified. If it is as likely to be the Flying Spaghetti Monster as it is the invisible man in the sky of ancient desert-dweller mythology, I can respect that.
When I read where Discovery Institute disavows belief in the God of the bible, I’ll take ID seriously.
Support Gonzalez. Support academic freedom. The Privileged Planet;Observational Astronomy Combat materialism. Read more on ID
You don’t believe that and neither do I.
Complex Specified Information - It’s not that hard to understand
Support Gonzalez. Support academic freedom. The Privileged Planet;Observational Astronomy Combat materialism. Read more on ID
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.