I don’t think your show measures up to American Idol.
You said that “Terrorist Idol” would alternate between “personal achievement and total abject humiliation.” I don’t see ANY “personal achievement” being demonstrated, just “total abject humiliation.”
I guess that may be the most important point. There is nothing entertaining about the Blame America First crowd and their desire to tear our country down. They are even willing to humiliate themselves to do it. At that, they have succeeded.
The audience is the Islamic jihadists, and to them they find the actions of Harry Reid and Rosie ODonnell to be VERY entertaining.