Yes, that is a refreshing point of view.
From one individual.
But as ladyjane pointed out, in MA it is the law to have a trooper or policeman on any kind of road construction. Their union lobbied for it. Some guys make way over 100k a year in overtime.
I could be wrong, but as I recall, beyond just lobbying for the law, they threatened to strike (or worse?) when abolishing paid details was proposed.