Posted on 03/17/2006 12:53:50 PM PST by SmithL
A federal appeals court today ruled Tennessee can sell license plates that promote "choose life," even though it doesn't offer one with an abortion rights message. A three-judge panel on the Sixth U-S Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati ruled in the appeal of a lawsuit by the American Civil Liberties Union of Tennessee. The group had sued over the specialty license plate approved by the Legislature in 2003 on First Amendment grounds and won a ruling against the tag from a lower court. Advertisement
In a 2-to-1 ruling this morning, the court concluded the one-sidedness on a contentious political issue may be ill-advised, but ruled the First Amendment doesn't prohibit it.
Extra fees motorists pay for the plates would go to New Life Resources -- an anti-abortion group.
The plates had stirred considerable debate. Governor Bredesen let the measure become law but declined to sign it. He also urged lawmakers to develop a new approach to deciding which causes would benefit from the sale of specialty plates.
Isn't that a "pro-choice" message?
Hmmmm - that looks like a white baby. I can see a problem here.
I don't like it. Think of Kalifornia doing a "Pro Choice" plate with no pro-life alternative if you think what Tennessee did was right. If that doesn't kick it for you, think of a "Homosexual Rights" plate.
California can be counted on to be offensive, however we do NOT HAVE A RIGHT to not being offended......and this is [depending on your point of view] as offensive as burning a FLAG or putting a crucifix in a bottle of urine.........Freedom of Speech is everyone's gift from GOD.
Why not. Let the liberals have a "Choose Death" license plate too, with the proceeds split between CAIR and Planned Parenthood.
They are, if for no other reason than abortion businesses like Planned Parenthood are allowed to pretend that they are charities.
Sure is nice of the Feds to let a sovereign state issue license plates that the libs don't like.
There is nothing to dislike here. The pro-abortion crowd can easily petition the state for their own license tag.
The pro-lifers have a picture of a cute happy baby on their license plate to demonstrate their position.
I wonder what the pro-choicers would picture on their license plate? Similarly with a "gay rights" plate. This is great, it would be forcing them to show everyone who they really are, and what they really stand for.
For everyone's info.
The reason there's no pro-choice plate is because they didn't get enough signatures. So they tried to stop the pro-life one from being made because of inequal rights, etc. Thankfully it was thrown out and the plate continued.
Just shows the people support life :)
Fricking hypocrites.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.