I understand the feeling (I grew up in Brooklyn), but I don't believe it.
The Jews of Israel are in mortal danger. Gathering millions of Jews together in a small space, surrounded by bloodthirsty enemies, with technology capable of killing most of them in minutes abroad in the world is amazingly risky.
Whaat stands in the way of another Holocaust is the existence of the United States and the relocation of a large fraction of the surviving Ashkenazi population to it.
Making aliyah is admirable from a faith perspective, but it's also a little nutty.
And, BTW, many people I knew in Brooklyn were always looking for the next Hitler in Nixon, or Ford, or Reagan. A lot of them, I gather, are still spinning the gragger at the mention of Bush and Cheney.
Talk about stuck on stupid!
Isn't that the point of faith? The idea is taking actions predicated on the conviction THE most decisive factor is not quantifiable.
Have you ever considered what it would take to "sell" Joshua's battle plan for Jericho to modern military commanders? :o)