Critic's Justification: "If she doesn't meet my arbitrary resume conditions X, Y, & Z, she is totally unqualified."
More pathetic.
"There are 1,084,504 lawyers in the U.S. What distinguishes Harriet Miers from any of them other than her connection with the president? To have selected her, when conservative jurisprudence has J. Harvie Wilkinson, Michael Luttig, Michael McConnell and at least a dozen others on a bench deeper than that of the New York Yankees, is scandalous." -Charles Krauthammer
That says it for me.