Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: MAD-AS-HELL
Bochco was right when he said his show would be non political, but he didn't say it would be accurate in portraying the military.

While rife with inaccuracies in all things dealing with the events which a light infantry squad faces in wartime, it has pretty much stayed nonpolitical. There is one character that somewhat voices a contrary view, but even so, it is through the eyes of a young man who is an idealist and is somewhat overwhelmed by the events surrounding him.

The sergeant in charge of the squad on which the series centers is portrayed as somewhat disgruntled at having had his tour extended by does not shirk away from doing his mission. While he is a bit of a firebreathing, kick-your-soldiers-in-the-ass NCO, he does care about his soldiers and gets irate when they do something stupid. The second episode in which they were manning a roadblock and his soldiers would not stay away from a shot up car brought this out. It seemed that at every moment he had to keep ordering his young troops away from the car because their curiosity kept gettting the best of them. It brought back a memory or two of my own dealings with knuckleheaded, curious privates.

While as far a good portrayal of proper military procedure it is a disaster ("Tour of Duty" was dozens of times better technically), "Over There" has not been critical of the war. Even the interegation episode did not show an Iraqi prisoner being trully abused, mostly just "vigorously" interogated. The show is not as left leaning as I had thought it would be.

Image hosted by Photobucket.com
What We Are About To Do Here Is What The Good Lord Would Call A Cleansing of the Wicked. I Call It A Good Old Fashioned Texas Ass Kicking.
14 posted on 08/24/2005 6:58:29 AM PDT by speed_addiction ( Somethings gnaw on a man worse'n dyin'!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies ]


To: speed_addiction
"While as far a good portrayal of proper military procedure it is a disaster"

I also find the show entertaining but very unrealistic. In the last episode, the squad (-) was trying to confirm that a person in a house was a terrorist spotter for an enemy mortar. They spent a lot of time wrestling with the morale dilemma of killing the suspect without conclusive proof. But, they never searched the house that the suspect was thought to be spotting from. Also, the whole mission was done at the direction of a quirky general who was obsessed with getting "American toilets" into the basecamp. The suggestion was that the general was risking his men's lives for toilets and, while not really political, seemed to be critical of operations there. All that being said, I have the show season-passed on my TEEVO.
16 posted on 08/24/2005 7:28:46 AM PDT by Airborne1986 (Well, you can do what you want to us. But we're not going to sit here while you badmouth the U.S.A.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson