Darn, that pesky 9th commandment gets in the way sometimes. Can't we write it out?
If you want to address Christian charity and forgiveness, as it applies to homosexuality, then argue that topic. However if you want to re-write "Thou shalt not bear false witness" into "Thou shalt not make a mistaken utterance", then you're on very thin ice. And given Eisner's terrible record, it was a very understandable mistake for clee1 to make (if indeed it is one).
--Boot Hill