Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Tanniker Smith
With all due respect to the genius of Tolkien (outstandingly creative author), if any of his works are the first read by our group this is going to turn into another Hobit Hole thread. While I strongly reccomend that everyone read his novels, they have already been discussed to the extent of having tens of thousands of posts here on FR. Lets not reinvent the wheel.
62 posted on 02/28/2005 6:38:26 AM PST by SouthParkRepublican (There are no contradictions... Only faulty premises.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies ]


To: SouthParkRepublican
Point well taken. That's not where I'd want to go. In fact, fantasy would be a great topic to discuss if only to find something non-Tolkien that isn't a load of ..., well, let's just say, something worth reading.

Too many of the medieval-style sword/sorcery fantasy stuff is just so horrible to read. So much of it is either based on Tolkien, based on a roleplaying game, based on a *computer* game, based on a *card* game or just poorly written. (It's even worse with the fanfic -- and this is coming from someone who used to write fanfic). And they tend to go on forever without resolution.

Actually, there is one series that I did like based on a single book I picked up for 39 cents at a Odd-Job: Ann Marston's "The Western King". It was the second book in a trilogy, but worked well as a standalone book. A few years passed before I thought to get the first book from the library ("Kingmaker's Sword"), excellent book, explained a couple of things in TWK that I missed. By the way, I reread the second book and loved it again.

THen I got the third book in the first trilogy. I couldn't believe the letdown, and not just because the word "First" was inserted before the word "trilogy". It seemed to have been written by an entirely different person. Instead of a third-person account, it went to a first-person narative (who had to comment on events from before she was born and do some of the exposition -- badly and repeatedly). Instead of the action taking place over a period of years (10-20), it happened pretty much in the span of a week. And much of the action happened "off-camera". Very frustrating.

I read the 4th and 5th books, but neither the Brooklyn nor NY Public Libraries have book six, and I'm so disappointed that I won't pay Amazon plus shipping for it.

But if you find the first two books, grab 'em. Good reads.

TS

63 posted on 02/28/2005 6:54:36 AM PST by Tanniker Smith (I didn't know she was a liberal when I married her.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 62 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson