1. Earl Warren was Eisenhower's first choice.
2. David Souter was certainly a compromise (as was Kennedy to a degree).
3. Sandra Day O'Conner was not properly vetted by Reagan in his haste to appoint a woman to the court.
Nevertheless, we were able to get Rehnquist elevated to Chief Justice (which took a lot) and we got two great conservatives in Scalia and Thomas.
Unfortunately, we gave Clinton every left-wing pinko he asked for, and certainly Hatch was complicit (if only through inaction) in this. IMHO
Hatch DEFINES the worthless check-pants RINO.