[batazoid]

I agree: “Subject to the Jurisdiction” of the United States” means exclusively only what Congress has passed laws establishing its jurisdiction for purposes of citizenship.

There are two kinds of “Birthright Citizenship”: Citizenship bestowed by the state and citizenship bestowed as a natural right. Citizenship bestowed by positive law is naturalization. Citizenship bestowed by citizen-parent(s) is natural citizenship.

Birthright citizenship

[DiogenesLamp]

I think you are in large part arguing with people who don't know what to think until a court tells them.

Too many people give too much deference to the "courts."

The Courts got steered wrong by William Rawle, and they have never recovered from the damage.