The ACOG has been well-proven in combat by our armed forces and the Israelis' so it's a natural choice. Luckily, I don't need two of them!
If I needed to use them in combat, which seems pretty unlikely, I would be perfectly comfortable with either the AR Mod 1 or the Viper PST. I also have a top end tactical Nikon Monarch on an Armalite AR10T which I liked a lot initially but now I feel like it really needs a Vortex PST so I'll probably sell it at some point and switch out.