Posted on 10/04/2014 1:08:54 PM PDT by EveningStar
My top two: Dizzy Dean and Steve Carlton--but I wouldn't argue with a quartet with Koufax and Ryan. Among today's pitchers, the only ones I think come close are Scherzer, Strasburg, Sale, and Price--and all four are young enough to get better.
On the other hand, Detroit revers Hank Greenberg because he did choose to play ball during the Jewish holy days. Go figure.
Don Drysale replace Koufax on the mound that day he got nail with hits when Dysdale came back off the mound I think he told Dodger coach you wish I was Jewish LOL!
Don’t forget Johnny Podres !
The weekly Shabbat is holier than Yom Kippur. Did he refuse to play on it as well?
“Respect,” Koufax responded before the 2014 season when asked by Jewish Week why he sat out the game.”
I thought Sandy Koufax had died.
“My top two: Dizzy Dean and Steve Carlton—”
Koufax, Carlton as the lefties, Gibson, Ryan as righties.As a lifelong Cards fan, cannot believe to this day that they traded Carlton. He was a monster
I didn't know that. Thanks for the info.
Did he refuse to play on it as well?
I doubt it.
Walter Johnson, of course, is the greatest pitcher of all time. Here is my top-ten list, not necessarily in order of rank:
Walter Johnson, Lefty Grove, Christy Mathewson, Warren Spahn, Grover Alexander, Steve Carlton, Tom Seaver, Bob Gibson, Sandy Koufax, Greg Maddux.
(I'm leaving Cy Young off because he pitched much of his career pre-1900.)
No Ryan but you put Maddux on the list? that’s ridiculus. A strikeout record that will never be broken and a no hitter record that will never be broken ranks in the top ten
Maddux clearly was the better pitcher, and virtually all baseball rankings will place them that way.
Ryan also holds the all-time walk record.
“Ryan also holds the all-time walk record”
A testament to his amazing longevity, another good reason for him to be in top 10
No, your rankings place them that way. I didn’t say he wasn’t a hall of famer, just not top ten. Bob Gibson didn’t win 300 games, was Maddux better than him too?
Don Drysdale was once asked about he reacted to a batter digging in in the batter’s box. Drysdale commented that the batter had better dig the hole deep enough to crawl in to because he was going to come after him.
These guys played real baseball!
Roberto Clemente would not tolerate an inside pitch. Pitchers usually avoided throwing them at him.
Bob Gibson always threw inside to Clemente on his first pitch.
What about Randy Johnson? Once he learned the craft, from advice from Nolan Ryan, he was pure domination.
Funny, you strategically left of K's and No hitters. Geez!!!!
Drysdale and Dizzy Dean may have been two of the meanest ever on the mound. As far as they were concerned the inner part of the plate belonged to them. If you didn't like it charge the mound!!
To put it in perspective, only 13 pitchers have struck out 300 in a season. Ryan’s 5712 roughly translates to doing that over 19 seasons.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.