Tebow's stats for 2011 were 126 completions in 271 attempts for a 46.5 completion percentage. He threw for 12 touchdowns, had 6 interceptions, ran for 660 yards and fumbled 13 times. He also had 6 delay of game penalties. Those are not exceptional stats by any measure.
Even in his last game with the Patriots he threw the winning TD in the 4th quarter.