[Resolute Conservative]

I think he is as good or better than these guys:

Tony Romo, Dallas (Tebow has better playoff record)
Andy Dalton, Cincinnati
Ryan Tannehill, Miami
Josh Freeman, Tampa Bay
Brandon Weeden, Cleveland
Jake Locker, Tennessee
E.J. Manuel, Buffalo
Blaine Gabbert, Jacksonville
Geno Smith, NYJ
Terrelle Pryor, Oakland

[RightFighter]

Oh please - Tony Romo is an elite quarterback. The Cowboys' inability to win playoff games has not been Tony Romo's doing. He had a terrible big-game record until 2009. Since then, the Cowboys, when they've won, have won BECAUSE OF him, and when they've lost, they've typically done so despite a great performance from Romo.

[Colonel_Flagg]

You left Christian Ponder off that list.

[MichaelCorleone]

I think you should add Mark Sanchez to your list.