Skip to comments.My MLB All-Star teams (Voting ends tonight)
Posted on 07/04/2013 10:55:57 AM PDT by Charles Henrickson
Voting for All-Star starters ends tonight at 11:59 p.m. (Eastern).
Here are my All-Star teams. 34 players on a team, at least 13 pitchers, every team must have a representative.
C: MOLINA, Posey
1B: VOTTO, Goldschmidt, Craig
2B: CARPENTER, Scutaro, Phillips
SS: SEGURA, Cabrera, Desmond
3B: WRIGHT, Alvarez
OF: GONZALEZ, Brown, Harper
OF: GOMEZ, McCutcheon
OF: BELTRAN, Cuddyer, Bruce
P (13; 9 S, 4 R): HARVEY, Kershaw, Wainwright, Zimmermann, Lee, Corbin, Locke, Wood, Fernandez; Melancon, Mujica, Kimbrel, Grilli
Honorable mention: 1B Freeman, OF Puig
C: MAUER, Santana
1B: DAVIS, Fielder
2B: CANO, Pedroia, Kipnis
SS: PERALTA, Lowrie
3B: CABRERA, Longoria, Donaldson
OF: TROUT, McLouth
OF: JONES, Ellsbury
OF: BAUTISTA, Cruz
DH: ORTIZ, Encarnacion
P (14; 10 S, 4 R): SCHERZER, Iwakuma, Hernandez, Darvish, Colon, Sale, Santana, Kuroda, Masterson, Norris; Crain, Robertson, Nathan, Rivera
Honorable mention: 2B Kendrick, 3B Machado
Some tough choices (NL C, NL 2B), some weak positions (NL 3B reserve, AL OF), some strong positions (NL 1B, AL 2B, AL 3B). Oh, and as a "Carlos" myself, I like my All-Carlos NL outfield: CarGon, CarGo, and CarBel. Also, while Kershaw or Wainwright would be good choices also for NL SP, I give the edge to Harvey, because the Mets are hosting the game.
OK, fellow baseball fans, what are your choices?
Good to see you have Jose Fernandez on the roster. Read his story sometime. It took him 3 tries to escape Fidel. When he finally got to Tampa he immediately insisted on taking 3 English courses each semester in HS.
In an otherwise season of misery (though they are looking better), he is a joy to watch for Marlins fans. For a 20 year old, his command is amazing.
America’s Pastime ping.
How about we have a position, most over paid verses performance. My nomination: A-Roid.
Normally I don't pick rookies--too small of a sample size (thus Puig only gets an honorable mention from me). But I had to pick someone from the Marlins, and he's having the best year. (Stanton would typically be the obvious choice, but he's missed a lot of time this year, and his numbers are only so-so for his standards.)
I saw this Fernandez pitch against the Cardinals, and he's the real deal.
Some big names, big contracts, perennial All-Stars, not playing at All-Star levels this year: Pujols, Hamilton, Holliday, Verlander, Sabathia, Cain. . . .
Phillips will start at 2nd base for the national league.
I live in the Seattle area, so I am glad to see these two on your roster. I think if there was a category for AL Top Two Pitchers in a Rotation on one of the Worst Teams in Baseball --- they would win hands down.
And he would be a good choice. NL 2B is strong this year. Phillips obviously gets the most career points, and he's the best defensively. His average is down, but his RBIs are up.
Matt Carpenter is raking this year. And he's doing surprisingly well at 2B. Scutaro is no slouch either, of course, and he came up big for the Giants last fall.
I’m a Tiger fan, looks like you got my picks already.
Anybody see Torii Hunter last night? Everybody gets angry sometimes but Hunter is about the last guy you expect to see heading for the pitchers mound.
Yes, I did. And I agree with him, sorta. I almost never pick a rookie for an All-Star team. Three months--or in Puig's case, two months--does not an All-Star make.
But Puig is SO hot, off to an incredible start, that it makes it tempting to put him on the team.
BTW, do you know who's doing almost as well this year as Puig, in terms of BA and OPS, for almost the same amount of PAs? Puig's teammate, Hanley Ramirez. But nobody's talking about him.
Torii Hunter came close to making my team as a reserve outfielder. I went with Nate McLouth instead. Which should tell you how weak the AL outfield is this year.
I've got three BoSox on my team: DH Ortiz, 2B Pedroia (reserve), and OF Ellsbury (reserve). P Buchholz would be on my team, but he's injured.
Imagine what King Felix’s career win total would be so far if he had been on good teams.
of Parra of the D Backs
Close. He's one of my "just miss" guys. Very good player, both offensively and defensively. Would not be a disgrace if he makes the team as a reserve.
the selection rules are a bit silly. A guy can come in 2nd place with 10% of the players’ vote and he is on the team. Even if the player behind him in 3rd place also makes the team due to one-player-each-team rule.
And why 2 Designated Hitters for AL? Elect one and let the manager decide during the game who pinch-hits for Ortiz.
Will they run out of pitchers if it goes 15 innings? that is still the drama.
How many guys from Missouri did CarlosHen select?
National League starting line up, the Saint Louis Cardinals!!
This is our year to win it all for Stan The Man Musial!
he’ll get his 2nd gold glove in his third full time year career this year 25 2 baggers.....301 avg....5 lead off homers this year
best of arm in the game
Not sure, but I think the rules state there has to be a second DH. I picked Encarnacion, whose stats are worthy, and he's been more DH than 1B or 3B this year, I think.
If it were up to me, of course, there would be no such thing as a DH. I'm a National League guy and an old-timey baseball purist.
How many guys from Missouri did CarlosHen select?
I, CarHen, a resident of Missouri, selected seven players (out of 68 total) from Missouri: one from Kansas City, Ervin Santana, and six from St. Louis: Molina, Carpenter, Beltran (starters), Craig (reserve), Wainwright and Mujica (pitchers). I do live in St. Louis, yes, but I also think these guys deserve to be on the team.
One of my favorite memories of my Dad...1961 All Star Game,Fenway Park.I was a young kid; we had box seats,first base side.Hot summer day (that turned ugly,resulting in the game being called at 1-1).The Red Sox had a rookie pitching sensation named Don Schwall who made the team.Musial comes up against Schwall...count 3-0.Then he starts fouling off pitch after pitch,it seemed to be about a dozen.My Dad leans over to me and says...and I remember his *exact* words.."you watch,Musial's just toying with this kid".Next pitch,Schwall strikes him out.Fenway went wild! And my Dad was no longer infallible!
I have been watching the Mariners play ball for decades now and there is one thing that stands out, among all the things wrong with the team. And, that is: No matter who is on the team; no matter who is the field Manager; no matter who is the General Manager; no matter who owns the team --- they simply cannot move a runner in scoring position across the plate. I don't know what it is about this team. I have, in my frustration, decided that as soon as a player's name is stiched on the back of a Mariner's jersey, they lose the ability to bring someone across homeplate who is in scoring position.
That is only one, of the many things, that is aggravating about being a Seattle Mariners fan.
Call them the Seattle Marooners.
you are correct that the player who finishes 2nd place to Ortiz in the player voting becomes the 2nd DH and automatic spot.
Silly, because half the AL teams do not have a full-time DH ... they rotate players based on opposing pitcher matchups, etc. Otherwise, the manager could use Kendrick as the DH or Kipnis or matchup vs. the pitcher game situation.
Encarnacion will be allowed to play the field if that is what the manager decides.
JOE TORRE will not be managing this year’s game, so maybe I will watch. And Ron washington will not be either. But, Leilich did a hack job on managing previous all-star games.
Freddie Freeman belongs at 1b for the national league in the asg. a .315 ba and he only has a salary of 550k this year? What a bargain !
If he played in an ESPN bias market like DC or ny, he’d be there, without question.
The problem is that NL 1B is so stacked this year. Votto and Goldschmidt have to be there, no question. I put Craig slightly ahead of Freeman. And Adrian Gonzalez would be a good choice, too. So there are five worthy, and two of those are locks.
Votto has a slightly better ba than freeman, but freeman has 15 more rbi’s.
He is also a better fielder.
Just looked it up:
Votto: 10 errors.
Freeman: 6 errors
There’s no way Votto is not on the team. He is an absolute lock. “All-Star” is not just about this year, three months. It’s also about what a guy has established himself to be. And Votto is the best in the league over the past few seasons.
I’m not saying he won’t make the team, just that freeman is already a better 1b.
The numbers don’t lie. King out...
Did you really pick Segura for the NL SS?
This guy...? Lol.
YOUR NL team is a good benchmark.
I’m not excited about Scutaro, but with Bochy the manager and a WS win, I give him a pass as a 2nd SF player.
Rosario C, COL could be a 3rd catcher
Tulowitzski might play. ???
i’M NOT into Melancon and Mujica
add Chapman? maybe Paul Maholm, if the Braves only have 1 player. Maybe Bumgarner, SF.
Cishek could be the Marlins choice over Fernandez.
Maybe Gregg over Wood for the Cubs’ selection.
Not everyone sold on Santana C, CLE
“It’s that defensive reputation that will likley keep him off the All-Star team. Joe Mauer looks like he’ll be voted in as the starter and Matt Wieters will probably get the backup nod via the players’ ballot. If there’s a third catcher chosen it’s more likely to be Jason Castro as the Astros’ representative.”
I go with Hardy BALT SS (he is going to make it regardless) and drop one of the OAK infielders ... (Donaldson or Lowrie) Lowrie defense is a question mark. Limited Range (?) plus 11 errors. (or drop both and add Coco Crisp CF, base stealer)
Add Kendrick and drop Crain, give CHW one player.
I already dropped Santana C above.
Robertson gives the NYY 4 players. Won’t kill me to see him not make it. Matt Moore, LHP, Tampa Bay
Howie is a good player...and good citizen!!
The selection show is today (Saturday) 630pm EST on Fox Sports TV, before the game of the week.
Rangers just signed Manny...he's in Triple AAA now. Didn't he retire rather than face another 50 game suspension for PEDs? So what happens to that?
all over it....got Daytona and my beloved D Backs today as well.....chillin a 12 pack of Boston Lager too
Manny served the 50 games last year while with Oakland organization (was on minor league roster)
Ball skipped under Morrisons glove allowing Jon Jay to score the winning run when he should have had to stop at third.
Stantons throw was only slightly better than the muzzie fags first pitch at a White Sox game a few years back.
The home plate umpire blew the game earlier on, but I agree. Stanton “lollygagged” the entire play. I can’t blame Morrison on that, and you could tell that LoMo was PISSED as he spit out his chew and stormed into the clubhouse.
Stanton is another that thinks things will just happen for him because he’s always been a head taller, a step faster, etc.
He needs to seriously change his outlook (not lifting weights, but listening to coaches) if he’s ever going to come close to reaching his potential.
Terrible way to end a game.
The Marlins have some good coaches too (unlike the motley crew they had last year with Guillen, those guys couldn't even correct Heath Bell).
Well, there's always tomorrow, hope Fernandez has another good outing, and Lance Lynn going for St. Louis.
I always wanted the Fish to let Stanton go to arbitration after this season, because I still think he’d be a bargain given his injuries.
But lately, I almost hope he hits 60 HR’s in the HR contest and they trade him for 1/2 of some other team’s prospects.
He doesn’t seem to have a very high baseball IQ.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.