Please Support Free Republic Today
If you don't care, we know how you feel, you don't have to post.
Randy, Mariah and Mr. Urban are okay, but the blonde, freaky, girl, not so much. They should have replace HER.
Hold it! I gotta’ get my giffashit card punched!
Haven’t watch any this year, but I think they need to replace the folks who are picking the judges.
Can I make the comment that both Carey and Lopez have VERY large derrieres?
Mariah is a dope. She has nothing to say about anything.
Minaj is quite possibly the most annoying person I have ever seen I my entire life.
Both of the drooling morons have ruined the show, and while I’m at it, I’m also sick of Randy “Hey Yo” Jackson.
for later
NOW we’re getting to the important stuff.
I say set up a mud wrestling pit on the Results Show and let the two of ‘em battle it out!
I stopped watching this year because of Nikki Minaj. She is horrible to watch. I don’t know if I had missed more than one or two episodes in a decade, and just stopped by the third week of this season.
We stopped watching this year too I miss Paula Abdul id dive on a pressure cooker for her anyday
My wife gave up on AI this year. Turned it on a couple of times, and didn’t last past about 20 minutes. She watched it through last year, though — and, by extension, I watched it, because it was on the big TV.
I think the format is getting tired. Its run its course. The judges are intolerable at this point. Cowell was the real draw. Slid quite a bit after he left. Tyler was alright last year, I guess. This year ... not even my wife could find a reason to give a damn.
SnakeDoc
I am not watching this season cannot stand that blonde woman. They should replace her.
Well, I didn’t watch back in the day, but have watched this entire season. I’m not impressed with the judges in general. The only one who has made cogent comments has been Keith Urban, actually. Mariah is too wary of being disliked for being judgmental and Nikki is too intent on making herself painfully clear. Randy does know his business but this is not the forum for a producer to really make points of value on-air. Only Urban has managed to bridge that divide.
And folks, it’s not about the judges, it’s about the contestants. And one of them really does have the potential to grow into an actual Ella Fitzgerald. Watch for the contestants, not the judges, okay?
Minaj is the token weirdo, but her comments are more in agreement with MY opinions than the others.
It is obvious (imo) the judges try to get rid of some and/or save some contestants and apparently America thinks better.
That weasily looking guy that is supposed to know what he's doing in suggesting music is an asshole and shouldn't even be ON the show.
Mariah is not only a hot milf, she's a calm assessment of talent.
Kieth is a level-headed opinionator.
"What difference does it make anyway?!!!"
Stunning news of cosmic import!
I don't blame you for thwarting the contemptuous posts, which are an attempt to shame viewers.
The show has had a great run and spawned imitators.
Most shows would be doing a "Celebrity" version by now.
On this show the celebrities are the judges, so not surprisingly they are given more face time than the contestants.
I venture that the author of this article has never seen the show. It is Randy, not Keith, who sits between the two women.
I do watch AI, but only because FR always has a live thread going. Don't think I could stomach it without the running freeper commentary.