I still say The Who, circa 1970 (see their Isle of Wight DVD) were the greatest band ever, when you consider the bassist, drummer, singer and guitarist. Watching Zeppelin live is boring compared to watching The Who in their prime.
I'm with you there. When you consider the total package. Songs, Recording quality, concerts, stage presence and talent of the individual members the Who wins that one quite easily. Townshend usually left the stage bleeding from his playing style. And every one of them were soaked in sweat and spent by the end of the performance. They never phoned it in.
Listen to the re-mastered Live at Leeds - 1971 -
Moon’s drumming is incredible. He and Bonham were both amazing, although different drumming styles.