The problem with the analogy is he didn’t turn the document over to someone with authority to act upon it. He posted it on a web site.
So far nobody legally has been given the right to ask for the real document. Even Sheriff Joe got it from the web site. His state is fine with the State of Hawaii saying they have a birth certificate on file.
Bennett's inquiries have taken quite a different tack. He is trying to decide whether or not to remove Obama from the AZ Ballot. Right now, HI will neither confirm nor deny if the the Web BC matches their records.
You make an excellent point, however. The fake BC was created to answer The Donald Trump, who is hardly an authoritative body! Team Obama has gone to great lengths NOT to present it to AZ. At this point, there is a lot of bluffing going on. Team Obama bets that Bennett, who has no stomach for this, having been forced into it by local outrage, is going to fold first. Frankly, I would rather face the wrath of Obama than an angry Sheriff Joe if I lived in AZ.
Interesting! Wonder why the Radio Guys don't find it so. Don't you?