And ... Allentown, Johnstown, Hazeltown, Erie ... lots of quasiCatholic Democrats in PA who resonant with Joe’s cafeteria-style Catholicism ... not to mention the progressives floating into Lancaster like locusts.
I was going by county colors on the 2016 electoral map.
Fortunately enough conservatives in the counties surrounding most 3rd class cities to keep ‘em red.
Harrisburg/Dauphin has been the outlier.