[Texas Eagle]

Aks her where StemExpress is buying baby body parts from if not Planned Barrenhood?

[Ray76]

Make her proof the videos are fake. Surely she must have some evidence to support her claim.

[kvanbrunt2]

the complete raw unedited videos are at their website. should be proof enough.

[silverleaf]

Has she actually watched them AND read the entire transcript?

Well then, what would a REAL abortion look like?
If those are actors why did the company get a judge to suppress the videos? The unedited videos are several hours long BTW ... how can you entrap someone when you give them 1-3 hours to chat over lunch or over a petri dish filled with baby parts? What was the gotcha moment?

No? he hasn’t watched them because someone told her they were fake? Thought so

A closed mind is a terrible thing to waste
Just keep feeding her tidbits of what is on the tapes
and tell her there are more to come and they are saving the worst for last

[Mamzelle]

They are not fakes. At least, you can know that. Don’t bother arguing. It is really her problem—to price that they are not fake us **not** your job. Lila Rose at liveaction.com is a resource.

[Proud2BeRight]

Does she deny that the people interviewed are not actual Planned Parenthood employees and those are their voices?

[PGalt]

my feminist sister

condolences, HerrBlucher

the great divide

It’s easy to jettison family members

freedom

[MNDude]

I would ask her something like “well, you could be right, these might all Hollywood effects and acting, but you would be in agreement that if somehow these crazy videos WERE real that the people in them are absolute monsters, right?”

[Slyfox]

When Cecile Richards makes the claim that they have been "edited" what she is really saying is that she knows that the tapes are for real.

She is just mad as hell that somebody got the best of them.

If they were fake Cecile could actually say that the abortionists portrayed in the videos are not from Planned Parenthood.

But she knows the women in the videos.

[Ray76]

There is no allegation that the videos are fake. There is an allegation that they are misleading.

National Abortion Federation (NAF) v. Center for Medical Progress, C15-3522

Complaint & Exhibits
http://www.cand.uscourts.gov/who/NAF_C15-3522

DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE RE: PLAINTIFF’S
APPLICATION FOR A TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER
http://media.aclj.org/pdf/Doc—22—Def—Resp—to-Pl—Mot—TRO_Redacted.pdf

[bboop]

Yes, make her prove her accusations. Do not fall into her trap of proving your point of view. Of course they are not fake/ duh. They are just regular conversations. Hugh Hewitt had a great point - we ONLY will win by saying it is infanticide. It is. That is non-negotiable. you can easily get waylaid by proving point by point.

I wouldn’t go there, personally. It is Mengele stuff, what the Nazis did to find out how their pilots would fare if shot down in the North Sea. Science without morals. Science without God. Science run amok. Ghoulish. Make HER squirm, don’t budge.

[smokingfrog]

The videos are absolutely accurate.

Ex-Planned Parenthood Director Abby Johnson Leaks All http://louderwithcrowder.com/exclusive-ex-planned-parenthood-director-abby-johnson-leaks-all/

[MNDude]

It is interesting that your sister is claiming the videos are fake although as far as I know not even planned parenthood is claiming the videos are fake. They are calling the videos invasion of a woman’s privacy. Why is she making a claim that even PP hasn’t made?

[RansomOttawa]

Any suggestions would be helpful before I respond to her.

Ask her why, after the first video, Cecile Richards apologized for its "tone." Why didn't she repudiate the content if the recording was a fake?

Thanks to CMP, the poor-choicers can never again accuse pro-life advocates of using "fake" abortion images in their presentation again. A video of someone poking through a casserole dish full of baby parts, in a Planned Parenthood facility, is far more grotesque than anything the Genocide Awareness Project has placarded on a college campus.

[Nachum]

If the videos are fake, why hasn’t Planned Parenthood responded to anything the video makers have said? The only thing that is fake is the notion that women are benefited by the slaughter of innocents.

[Nevadan]

Planned Parenthood isn't denying that they sell baby body parts. They are just denying that they are profiting from it - even though the videos indicate that they are profiting. What they are denying is that there is anything wrong with what they are doing. It sounds bad and looks bad but they are really doing something "good".

Those who are criticizing the videos complain that the videos are edited. This sounds bad until you consider that all videos are edited to some degree. All news channels edit. 60 Minutes edits. 20/20 edits. Now if they are splicing and dicing so as to put words in Planned Parenthood's mouth, that would be a problem. But what they have done instead is cut the tapes to smaller, more digestible parts while making the entire unedited tapes available for anyone interested. (Something news organizations don't do)