WA: Example of One Punch Homicide

Gun Watch ^ | 26 December, 2014 | Dean Weingarten

[marktwain]

Thomas, above, died after being struck with one punch.

On December 21st, just before Christmas, there occurred a tragic example of a one punch homicide.  It seems clear that the homicide was unintentional, as the victim agreed to be hit.   Both young men were at a party and appear to have been drinking.  From khou.com:

Before the fight, the two shook hands and smoked a cigarette together, witnesses told sheriff's deputies. Thomas, who apparently hit a car that the suspect was sitting in, agreed to let Galen hit him.

But Galen hit Thomas so hard that he fell backward on the pavement and never regained consciousness, sheriff's spokeswoman Shari Ireton said. After friends could not revive Thomas, one drove him to Providence Regional Medical Center in Everett, Wash., where he later died.

This is a graphic example that a punch to the head is potential deadly force.   It is important to understand this; once you know this to be true, you can testify that you did, and a prosecutor and jury can be informed that you had this knowledge. 

The law about the justification of using deadly force is based, in part, on the "reasonable person" doctrine.   A jury would be instructed to determine if someone claiming self defense acted  as a "reasonable person" might, knowing what they knew, in the situation that they found themselves. 

In this case, there was no justification; the victim agreed to be punched. 

But that is not true in most cases.   For a list of hundreds of people killed with one punch, we owe a debt of gratitude to Steve Kokette of Madison, Wisconsin,  who has compiled such a list at onepunchhomicide.com.

One life ended, one likely ruined for the future;  this is a tragic case.

©2014 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice is included.
Link to Gun Watch

[marktwain]

A punch can kill.

[Codeflier]

BS. Just look at a fight scene in any movie or the WWE. People can take countless punches right to the head. :)

[Jack Hydrazine]

There’s punch drunk and then there’s punch dead!

[M.K. Borders]

Happened here recently.

50 year old drunk who never grew up decided to get into it with a couple of 20 somethings in the bar parking lot.

He swung first, missed and the young man tagged him right between the eyes. Straightened up and fell back, head to concrete, no resistance. There is a body of thought suggesting that he died on the way to the ground.

Idiot. Got himself killed. Badly damaged his family and ruined a young man's life. Not to mention there is a real possibility of another killing now. An endless cycle of stupid.

[FreeAtlanta]

[Gay State Conservative]

If the kid agreed to be punched then he shares responsibility for his fate IMO.Maybe not legally but certainly morally.

[eartrumpet]

Just like Houdini.

[Oatka]

Just look at a fight scene in any movie or the WWE. People can take countless punches right to the head. :)

Indeed, and their faces rarely show a mark, swell up, or show bruising later on.

[muir_redwoods]

A good friends brother was at a wedding reception. Behind him and completely unbeknownst to him, at another table an argument suddenly became physical. One drunk threw a roundhouse punch, missing his intended target and hit Pete square in the back of his head. Pete went face down in his meal dead.