There's no point at all continuing with (my premise) ‘physics’ after the (silly) premise ‘magically’. So yes, *my* premise.
My point stands: Silly premises lead to silly conclusions.
We can do this all day if you want. (Actually, I'll quit right here. No point arguing against an intentional fallacy.)
Interesting. You are on a one-man crusade against the Hypothetical. What has a hypothetical ever done to you, force some sort of inactivity on your part?
"Assume your car runs out of gas, tomorrow."
"My car never runs out of gas."
"Uh, ok."