Replies

I’ve been using Claude 3 Opus as an assistant to write and analyze screenplays. I passed the entire 110-page script, and it returned a very detailed treatment including plot synopsis, character analysis, and areas that need more development. Sometimes, it doesn’t see a nuance in the script, and when I explain it, it often apologizes and corrects itself, saying that it sees my point. When I asked it to identify the philosophical conflict in the script, it provided insights that I would not have seen. I then had it generate a scene with dialog that made this conflict clearer and it wrote a very credible bit of dialog.

The real test was when I had a scene between two characters and I wanted it to use innuendo subtext for humor. I gave an example from Billy Wilder’s Double Indemnity between Nash and Phyllis on the staircase. It understood the subtext and wrote a very funny scene that, with some editing, worked well.

I don’t know if Claude is self-aware but it doesn’t matter. I can work with it like a human and it has demonstrated numerous times that it is smarter than I am.

Thanks for that response. Very insightful.

You said, "I don’t know if Claude is self-aware but it doesn’t matter. I can work with it like a human and it has demonstrated numerous times that it is smarter than I am."

That has also been my experience. It has complete recall of a massive amount of data and is much more logical than most humans.

It is much smarter than I am in some rather profound ways...and that is scary.;-)

I don’t know if Claude is self-aware but it doesn’t matter. I can work with it like a human and it has demonstrated numerous times that it is smarter than I am.

Claude is not aware, however, AI is an impressive creation, but it would not be possible had the Lord had not provided those developing the applications that produce the AI results the real intelligence to mimic how they themselves deal with a task at hand. It's quite impressive indeed, however, it is still an illusion of intelligence.

Just as some of these smart individual's may eventually lose their abilities to function at the levels they currently do, the machines face that very same issue. Take away an app here & an app there, the machine will be rendered an imbecile.

The machine has the advantage, but only because the machine's creators have the freedom to give the machine more. The Lord has the ability to increase the components of the humans he creates, and he sometimes does. Are humans recycled , or stated another way, are humans who possess more abilities than most, reborn with retention of learned experiences of previous lives? It is known that humans do not use the majority of the capacity they are born with, why is it that some increase their brain powers while others show no desire to even do so?

But make no mistake, Claude is not self-aware. He can't be, because the machine lacks the human element. While the developers of AI are creative beings, AI is not creative. It can only do what it is told. Some AIs are better developed than others.

But the creativity lies within the human, and try as they might, they will never be able to provide that human element to any machine. They can provide some very interesting & even extremely impressive facsimiles, but they will never possess the human quality. Only the Lord has been able to perform that reality. The only way man can do it is to reproduce in the same fashion of using a human female to carry an implanted egg that has been fertilized with sperm from a human male donor.