Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: BroJoeK
What you wrote is only partly true!

Read "THUNDER AT TWILIGHT" for starters.

You apparently are stuck with your opinion, that you read in one book, without understanding the entire picture; nor what preceded it all, diplomacy of that time, the complete player list, nor why that war could have been at the least, somewhat forestalled.

135 posted on 09/13/2019 6:59:38 PM PDT by nopardons
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 134 | View Replies ]


To: nopardons
nopardons: "You apparently are stuck with your opinion, that you read in one book, without understanding the entire picture; nor what preceded it all, diplomacy of that time, the complete player list, nor why that war could have been at the least, somewhat forestalled. "

My little library of First World War books begins with Tuchman & Fromkin, includes MacMillan, Ferguson, Keegan, Mossier & Catherwood.
Today there are very few who still find the Great War controversial enough to debate, but there are still many who buy the German propaganda -- which Germans like Hitler himself believed -- that first, Germans did not start it and second, that Germans did not lose that war.

It's what drove Germans to Round Two in 1939.

In fact, by 1900 Germany was the great revisionist power, growing population, growing industrial power, growing cultural influence, growing military prowess.
And "lebensraum" was not something Hitler invented, it was around when Hitler was born.
So Fromkin's book "Europe's Last Summer" reviews the age overall and then reveals events between the Kaiser's High Command and Austria -- how Germans pushed reluctant Austrians into war and then responded to mobilization by Russia with a German invasion of... Belgium & France.

Sure, other countries played roles too -- by refusing to accept Austria's aggression against Serbia, or refusing to accept Germany's declaration of war against Russia, they expanded a small local conflict into global war.
But it all began with the Kaiser's High Command pushing reluctant Austrians to issue war ultimatums and then not accept Serbia's compliant response.

Fromkin's c2004 chapter titles:

    Prologue
    Out of the Blue
    The Importance of the Question
    A Summer to Remember

    Part One: Europe's Tensions

  1. Empires Clash
  2. Classes Struggle
  3. Nations Quarrel
  4. Countries Arm
  5. Zarathustra Prophesies
  6. Diplomats Align

    Part Two: Walking Through Minefields

  7. The Eastern Question
  8. A challenge for the Archduke
  9. Explosive Germany

    Part Three: Drifting Toward War

  10. Macedonia -- Out of Control
  11. Austria -- First off the Mark
  12. France and Germany Make their Play
  13. Italy Grasps; Then the Balkans Do Too
  14. The Slavic Tide
  15. Europe Goes to the Brink
  16. More Balkan Tremors
  17. An American Tries to Stop it

    Part Four: Murder!

  18. The Last Waltz
  19. In the Land of the Assassins
  20. The Russian Connection
  21. The Terrorists Strike
  22. Europe Yawns
  23. Disposing of the Bodies
  24. Rounding up the Suspects

    Part Five: Telling Lies

  25. Germany signs a Blank Check
  26. The Great Deception
  27. Berchtold Runs Out of Time
  28. The Secret is Kept

    Part Six: Crisis!

  29. The Fait is not Accompli
  30. Presenting an Ultimatum
  31. Serbia More or Less Accepts

    Part Seven: Countdown

  32. to 42: Day by Day timeline of events

    Chapter 43: Shredding the Evidence

    Part Eight: Conclusion, the Mystery Solved

    Epilogue

From Chapter 20: The Russian Connection:
137 posted on 09/15/2019 6:07:52 AM PDT by BroJoeK ((a little historical perspective...))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 135 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson