I really liked Caleb, too. The judges’ comments seemed so-so compared to how well he did. I wonder if he’s not their pick to win.
The judges are completely useless. They praise everything, but say nothing.
As an experiment, we've substituted this lifeless rock for one of the Idol contestants. Let's see what happens ...
Katy: You rocked it. Did he rock you, mom? You can't have him, mom! He's my rock!
Lionel: My friend, in my early days with the Commodores, I thought I could rock. But you, my friend, are the rock.
Luke: I don't even know what to say, man. I'm from Georgia. We're experts on clay, not rock. You just keep being you, man! Shooo-weeee!