I'm shocked, Peggy.
What ever gave you that idea? :)
Posted on 03/11/2018 5:22:20 AM PDT by silent_jonny
Top 5 in no special order
Cade
Maddie
Michael
Gabby
Catie
Top 3
Gabby
Michael
Cade
Top 2
Michael.... ( gets the advantage of split votes between cade and gabby)
Gabby
Winner
Michael.......... new, different , very likable......
We shall see....
I prefer Maddie to any of them...
Caleb is growing on me too, I think he may be a finalist with Catie...
My top 10 this week was based on this weeks performances, but all along I have been thinking that the Final will be Cade vs Gabby with Michael as a dark horse.
Michael has upped his game the last couple weeks for sure, and Cade basically showed he will struggle outside his comfort zone.
I still will stay with my prediction though that Gabby is this years champion.
Catie cannot stand the rigors of the tour...unless her very wealthy folks supply her with a an entourage including a doctor, psychiatrist, bodyguards, dressers, publicists and coaches, ...these parents, sooner or later, must realize her limitations, which are obvious to the casual viewer.
I like Maddie waaay better than Gabby. Gabby is very artificial.
Michael has upped his game the last couple weeks for sure, and Cade basically showed he will struggle outside his comfort zone.
I still will stay with my prediction though that Gabby is this years champion.
Good choice and analysis. Won’t be disappointed if she wins...
I prefer Maddie to any of them...
Like her too, and if she gets in top 3 could be very interesting between her and Gabby.
True. But Katy is funny. (When she's not drinking booze from a shoe)
I'm shocked, Peggy.
What ever gave you that idea? :)
If he had a chance of surviving this week, it shriveled up and died the moment his man-bunned fiancé bounced onto the screen. Even "tolerance" has a limit.
She's like Megyn Kelly, can't warm up to her fakeness. Now J Lo seemed "sincere" and a nicer person.
Catie will win if they can get her the right meds!
good grief, there are actually two of them!
That’s what I was thinking! They look alike-even the same man bun!
All the meds in the world will not help that dear sweet girl to become an American Idol.
it would be the greatest upset since taylor hicks! :)
Possible but not probable. Anyway...she’s a sweetie and I wish her the best of luck!
Pre show indicator of what contestants will sing.
3100
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.