Women are generally better at seeing when another women is handing them a line, just as men can hear another man tell a story and know it does not quite hang together.
Taking gifts from and staying in touch with the guy you claimed raped you is going to set off the "something ain't right" detector.
Is Cosby a pervert? Yep. But not the point.
Did Cosby ever rape any of them? Maybe. But in this case I would have to say there is enough doubt that it would be tough for me to convict.
If a woman is raped, usually she doesn't wait a year to notify authorities, which she did.
They settled the civil suit for an "undisclosed amount" and that deposition was to remain sealed. The AP had it unsealed, which brings us to this point.