Trophy hunting IS good for the herd. Imagine if Tom Brady is in the town and continually beats down every weaker man in the town and impregnates all the women. Say it goes on a few years. Soon, the genetics of the herd are getting similar as his half sibling descendants meet and mate.
So someone comes in and shoots Brady and puts his antlers on the wall.
Other males start breeding, and the genetic variety and the health of the herd rapidly improves.
There is nothing whatsoever wrong with trophy hunting. By the time you get him, he has spread his genes sufficiently.
Are you advocating killing Tom as a trophy??